← Kaccāyana-Byākaraṇaṃ
Kaccāyana-Byākaraṇaṃ
Kaccāyana's Grammar
3-Kāraka-Kappa · 3-Case Chapter
Bilingual Pāḷi–English edition · 45 suttas · 1 sectionv1.0ESEN
100% 0 / 45 studied
Kaṇḍa:
Chaṭṭha-Kaṇḍa· Sixth section
271Kaccāyana Sutta. 88, 308Rūpasiddhi Suttas.Yasmād apeti bhayam ādatte vā tad apādānaṃ (555, 557)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Yasmā + apeti + bhayaṃ + ādatte + vā + taṃ + apādānaṃ = 7 words]

Yasmā vā apeti, yasmā vā bhayaṃ jāyate, yasmā vā ādatte, taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Gāmā apenti munayo; nagarā niggato rājā; corā bhayaṃ jāyate; ācariyupajjhāyehi sikkhaṃ gaṇhāti sisso.

Apādānam icc anena kvattho? Apādāne pañcamī.

That from which [one] moves away, [from which] danger or fear [arises], or from which one takes: that is “apādāna”.
That from which [one] moves away, that from which danger or fear arises, or that from which [one] takes: that case has the name “ablative”.1Translator's note: From now on the term “apādāna” is translated as “ablative”.

As what?

  1. Gāmā apenti munayo (the sages go away from the village).
  2. Nagarā niggato rājā (the king has gone out of the city).
  3. Corā bhayaṃ jāyate (danger or fear arises from the thief).
  4. Ācariyupajjhāyehi sikkhaṃ gaṇhāti sisso (the student takes the training from the teachers and preceptors).

What is the use of the name “apādāna” (ablative)?2Footnote: “Kvattho” can be read as “ko attho” (what is the use?) or as “kva attho” (where is the use?). For the use of the name “apādāna” in the sutta “Apādāne pañcamī” (§295). In the ablative, the fifth [inflection].


1Translator's note: From now on the term “apādāna” is translated as “ablative”.
2Footnote: “Kvattho” can be read as “ko attho” (what is the use?) or as “kva attho” (where is the use?).
272Kaccāyana Sutta. 309Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Dhātu-nāmānam upasaggayogādīsv api ca (558, 568)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Dhātu-nāmānaṃ + upasaggayogādīsu + api + ca = 4 words]

Dhātu-nāmānaṃ payoge ca upasaggayogādīsv api ca taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Dhātūnaṃ payoge tāva ji icc etassa dhātussa parāpubbassa payoge yo asaho, so apādānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Buddhasmā parājenti aññatitthiyā.

Bhū icc etassa dhātussa papubbassa payoge yato acchinnappabhavo, so apādānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Himavatā pabhavanti pañca mahānadiyo (MA. iii, 26)Majjhima-nikāya-aṭṭhakathā · vol. iii, p. 26; Anavatattamhā pabhavanti mahāsarā; Aciravatiyā pabhavanti kunnadiyo.

Nāmappayoge pi taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Urasmā jāto putto; bhūmito niggato raso; ubhato sujāto putto mātito ca pitito ca (D. i, 106, 113)Dīgha-nikāya.

Upasaggayoge3Footnote: Upasaggayogādīsv api ca (K). taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Apasālāya āyanti vāṇijā; ābrahmalokā saddo abbhuggacchati (Vin. i, 21)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. i, p. 21; upari pabbatā4Footnote: Pari pabbatā (K). devo vassati; buddhasmā pati Sāriputto dhammadesanāya bhikkhū ālapati temāsaṃ; ghatam assa telasmā pati dadāti; uppalam assa padumasmā pati dadāti; kanakam assa hiraññasmā pati dadāti.

Ādiggahaṇena kārakamajjhe pi pañcamīvibhatti hoti. Ito pakkhasmā vijjhati migaṃ luddako; (ito) kosā5Footnote: Ito kosā (Sī). vijjhati kuñjaraṃ; (ito) māsasmā6Footnote: Ito māsasmā (Sī). bhuñjati bhojanaṃ.

Apiggahaṇena nipātapayoge pi pañcamīvibhatti hoti dutiyā ca tatiyā ca. Rahitā mātujā puññaṃ katvā dānaṃ7Footnote: Bhāgaṃ (Suttaniddesa). deti, rahitā mātujaṃ, rahitā mātujena vā. Rite saddhammā kuto sukhaṃ labhati, rite saddhammaṃ, rite saddhammena vā. Te bhikkhū nānā kulā pabbajitā (Vin. i, 9)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. i, p. 9. Vinā saddhammā natth’ añño koci nātho loke vijjati, vinā saddhammaṃ, vinā saddhammena vā; vinā buddhasmā, vinā buddhaṃ, vinā buddhena vā.

Caggahaṇena aññatthā pi pañcamīvibhatti hoti. Yato ’haṃ bhagini ariyāya jātiyā jāto (M. ii, 306)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 306. Yato sarāmi attānaṃ (Khu. vi, 175)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. vi, p. 175; yato patto ’smi viññutaṃ (Khu. vi, 175)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. vi, p. 175; yatv ādhikaraṇam enaṃ cakkhundriyaṃ asaṃvutaṃ viharantaṃ abhijjhādomanassā pāpakā akusalā dhammā anvāsaveyyuṃ (D. i, 66; S. ii, 384)Dīgha-nikāya · Saṃyutta-nikāya.

[When there is connection with] roots and nouns, and when there is connection with prefixes and others, also [there is the ablative].
When there is connection with roots and nouns, and when there is connection with prefixes and others, that case also has the name “ablative”.
First, when there is connection with roots: in connection with the root ‘ji’ preceded by ‘parā’, that which cannot be conquered8Translator's note: “Asaho” can also be translated as “without opposition/opponent”. has the name “ablative”.

As what?

  1. Buddhasmā parājenti aññatitthiyā (the adherents of other teachers were defeated by the Buddha).

In connection with the root ‘bhū’ preceded by ‘pa’, that from which there is an uninterrupted flow has the name “ablative”.

As what?

  1. Himavatā pabhavanti pañca mahānadiyo (the five great rivers originate from the Himalayas).
  2. Anavatattamhā pabhavanti mahāsarā (the great lakes originate from the [lake] Anavatatta).
  3. Aciravatiyā pabhavanti kunnadiyo (the small rivers originate from the [river] Aciravatī).

Also in connection with nouns, that case has the name “ablative”.

As what?

  1. Urasmā jāto putto (a son born from the breast).
  2. Bhūmito niggato raso (the essence comes out from the earth).
  3. Ubhato sujāto putto mātito ca pitito ca (a son well born from both, from the mother and from the father).

In connection with prefixes,9Footnote: Upasaggayogādīsv api ca (K). that case has the name “ablative”.

As what?

  1. Apasālāya āyanti vāṇijā (the merchants go avoiding the [customs] hall).
  2. Ābrahmalokā saddo abbhuggacchati (the sound spreads as far as the world of Brahmā).
  3. Upari pabbatā10Footnote: Pari pabbatā (K). devo vassati (the rain falls above the hill).11Footnote: Another reading is “pari pabbatā devo vassati”, the rain falls avoiding the hill.
  4. Buddhasmā pati Sāriputto dhammadesanāya bhikkhū ālapati temāsaṃ (substituting the Buddha, Sāriputta calls the bhikkhus to preach the Dhamma for three months).
  5. Ghatam assa telasmā pati dadāti ([he] gives him butter instead of oil).
  6. Uppalam assa padumasmā pati dadāti ([he] gives him a lily instead of a lotus).
  7. Kanakam assa hiraññasmā pati dadāti ([he] gives him gold instead of silver).

By taking “ādi”, there is also the fifth inflection in the middle of cases.

  1. Ito pakkhasmā vijjhati migaṃ luddako (the hunter pierces [will pierce] the deer fifteen days from now).
  2. (Ito) kosā12Footnote: Ito kosā (Sī). vijjhati kuñjaraṃ ([he] pierces the elephant a kosa13Translator's note: A measure of length equivalent to a quarter of a yojana. from here).
  3. (Ito) māsasmā bhuñjati bhojanaṃ ([he] eats the food a month from now).

By taking “api”, there is also the fifth inflection in connection with particles, and also the second and the third [inflection].

  1. Rahitā mātujā puññaṃ katvā dānaṃ deti (without a son, having done merit, [he] gives); rahitā mātujaṃ, rahitā mātujena vā.
  2. Rite saddhammā kuto sukhaṃ labhati (without the good Dhamma, where can [one] get happiness?); rite saddhammaṃ, rite saddhammena vā.
  3. Te bhikkhū nānā kulā pabbajitā (those bhikkhus went forth from various families).
  4. Vinā saddhammā natth’ añño koci nātho loke vijjati (without the good Dhamma, there is no other refuge existing in the world); vinā saddhammaṃ, vinā saddhammena vā; vinā buddhasmā, vinā buddhaṃ, vinā buddhena vā.

By taking “ca”, there is also the fifth inflection in other meanings.

  1. Yato ’haṃ bhagini ariyāya jātiyā jāto (sister, from the time I was born with the Noble birth).
  2. Yato sarāmi attānaṃ (from the time I remember myself).
  3. Yato patto ’smi viññutaṃ (from the time I came to the use of reason).
  4. Yatv ādhikaraṇam enaṃ cakkhundriyaṃ asaṃvutaṃ viharantaṃ abhijjhādomanassā pāpakā akusalā dhammā anvāsaveyyuṃ (for that reason, evil and unwholesome dhammas, covetousness and grief, torment [the bhikkhu] who dwells unrestrained in the eye-faculty).

3Footnote: Upasaggayogādīsv api ca (K).
4Footnote: Pari pabbatā (K).
5Footnote: Ito kosā (Sī).
6Footnote: Ito māsasmā (Sī).
7Footnote: Bhāgaṃ (Suttaniddesa).
8Translator's note: “Asaho” can also be translated as “without opposition/opponent”.
9Footnote: Upasaggayogādīsv api ca (K).
10Footnote: Pari pabbatā (K).
11Footnote: Another reading is “pari pabbatā devo vassati”, the rain falls avoiding the hill.
12Footnote: Ito kosā (Sī).
13Translator's note: A measure of length equivalent to a quarter of a yojana.
273Kaccāyana Sutta. 310Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Rakkhaṇatthānam icchitaṃ (569)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Rakkhaṇa-atthānaṃ + icchitaṃ = 2 words]

Rakkhaṇatthānaṃ dhātūnaṃ payoge yaṃ icchitaṃ, taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Kāke rakkhanti taṇḍulā; yavā paṭisedhenti gāvo.

That which is desired [in connection with] those meaning protection.
When there is connection with roots having the meaning of protection, that which is desired, that case has the name “ablative”.

  1. Kāke rakkhanti taṇḍulā (they keep the crows away from the rice).
  2. Yavā paṭisedhenti gāvo (they keep the cows away from the barley).
274Kaccāyana Sutta. 311Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Yena vā ’dassanaṃ (570)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Yena + vā + adassanaṃ = 3 words]

Yena vā adassanam icchitaṃ, taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Upajjhāyā antaradhāyati sisso; mātarā ca pitarā ca antaradhāyati putto.

Vā ti kimatthaṃ? Sattamīvibhatyatthaṃ. Jetavane antaradhāyati Bhagavā.

Optionally, by whom not being seen [is desired].
Optionally, that by whom not being seen is desired: that case has the name “ablative”.

  1. Upajjhāyā antaradhāyati sisso (the student hides from the preceptor).
  2. Mātarā ca pitarā ca antaradhāyati putto (the son hides from the mother and the father).

What is the purpose of saying “vā” (optionally)? To [allow] the meaning of the seventh inflection. Jetavane antaradhāyati Bhagavā (the Blessed One disappeared in [from] Jetavana).

275Kaccāyana Sutta. 312Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Dūr’-antik’-addhakālanimmāna-tvālopa-disāyoga-vibhatt’-ārappayoga-suddha-ppamocana-hetu-vivitta-ppamāṇa-pubbayoga-bandhana-guṇavacana-pañha-kathana-thokākattūsu ca (571)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Dūra-antika-addhakālanimmāna-tvālopa-disāyoga-vibhatta-ārappayoga-suddha-ppamocana-hetu-vivitta-ppamāṇa-pubbayoga-bandhana-guṇavacana-pañha-kathana-thoka-akattūsu + ca = 2 words]

Dūratthe, antikatthe, addhanimmāne, kālanimmāne, tvālope, disāyoge, vibhatte, ārappayoge, suddhe, pamocane, hetvatthe, vivittatthe, pamāṇe, pubbayoge, bandhanatthe, guṇavacane, pañhe, kathane, thoke, akattari ca icc etesv atthesu payogesu ca, taṃ kārakaṃ apādānasaññaṃ hoti.

Dūratthe tāva: Kīvadūro ito Naḷakāragāmo. Dūrato v’ āgamma. Ārakā te moghapurisā imasmā dhammavinayā. Dutiyā ca tatiyā ca. Dūraṃ gāmaṃ āgato, dūrena gāmena vā āgato. Ārakā imaṃ dhammavinayaṃ, anena dhammavinayena vā icc evamādi.

Antikatthe: Antikaṃ gāmā; āsannaṃ gāmā; samīpaṃ gāmā. Samīpaṃ saddhammā. Dutiyā ca tatiyā ca. Antikaṃ gāmaṃ, antikaṃ gāmena vā. Āsannaṃ gāmaṃ, āsannaṃ gāmena vā. Samīpaṃ gāmaṃ, samīpaṃ gāmena vā. Samīpaṃ saddhammaṃ, samīpaṃ saddhammena vā icc evamādi.

Addhanimmāne: Ito Mathurāya catūsu yojanesu Saṅkassaṃ nāma nagaraṃ atthi; tattha bahū janā vasanti icc evamādi.

Kālanimmāne: Ito bhikkhave ekanavutikappe Vipassī nāma Bhagavā loke udapādi (D. ii, 2)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 2. Ito tiṇṇaṃ māsānaṃ accayena parinibbāyissati (D. ii, 89)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 89 icc evamādi.

Tvālope kammādhikaraṇesu: Pāsādā saṅkameyya (S. i, 96)Saṃyutta-nikāya · vol. i, p. 96, pāsādaṃ abhiruhitvā (saṅkameyya) vā. Pabbatā saṅkameyya, pabbataṃ abhiruhitvā (saṅkameyya) vā. Hatthikkhandhā saṅkameyya (S. i, 96)Saṃyutta-nikāya · vol. i, p. 96, hatthikkhandhaṃ abhiruhitvā (saṅkameyya) vā. Āsanā vuṭṭhaheyya, āsane nisīditvā (vuṭṭhaheyya) vā icc evamādi.

Disāyoge: Avīcito yāva upari bhavaggam antare bahū sattanikāyā vasanti. Yato khemaṃ tato bhayaṃ (Khu. v, 193)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. v, p. 193. Puratthimato, dakkhiṇato, pacchimato, uttarato aggī pajjalanti. Yato assosuṃ bhagavantaṃ. Uddhaṃ pādatalā adho kesamatthakā (D. ii, 233)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 233 icc evamādi.

Vibhatte: Yato paṇītataro vā visiṭṭhataro vā natthi. Chaṭṭhī ca. Channavutīnaṃ pāsaṇḍānaṃ dhammānaṃ pavaraṃ, yad idaṃ sugatavinayo icc evamādi.

Ārappayoge: Gāmadhammā vasaladhammā asaddhammā ārati virati paṭivirati (Khu. viii, 42)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. viii, p. 42; pāṇātipātā veramaṇī icc evamādi.

Suddhe: Lobhaniyehi dhammehi suddho asaṃsaṭṭho (M. ii, 383)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 383. Mātito ca pitito ca suddho asaṃsaṭṭho anupakuddho agarahito (D. i, 106; M. ii, 377)Dīgha-nikāya · Majjhima-nikāya icc evamādi.

Pamocane: Parimutto dukkhasmā ti vadāmi (S. ii, 26)Saṃyutta-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 26. Mutto ’smi Mārabandhanā. Na te muccanti maccunā icc evamādi.

Hetvatthe: Kasmā hetunā, kena hetunā, kissa hetunā (M. i, 1; D. ii, 58)Majjhima-nikāya · Dīgha-nikāya. Kasmā nu tumhaṃ daharā na mīyare (Khu. v, 214)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. v, p. 214. Kasmā idh’ eva maraṇaṃ bhavissati icc evamādi.

Vivittatthe: Vivitto pāpakā dhammā, vivicc eva kāmehi, vivicca akusalehi dhammehi icc evamādi.

Pamāṇe: Dīghaso navavidatthiyo sugatavidatthiyā; pamāṇikā kāretabbā (Vin. ii, 225)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. ii, p. 225; majjhimassa purisassa aḍḍhateḷasahatthā icc evamādi.

Pubbayoge: Pubbe ’va sambodhā (M. i, 219; A. i, 261)Majjhima-nikāya · Aṅguttara-nikāya icc evamādi.

Bandhanatthe: Satasmā bandho naro. Tatiyā ca. Satena bandho naro raññā iṇatthena icc evamādi.

Guṇavacane: Puññāya sugatiṃ yanti; cāgāya vipulaṃ dhanaṃ; paññāya vimuttimano; issariyāya janaṃ rakkhati rājā icc evamādi.

Pañhe tvālope kammādhikaraṇesu: Abhidhammā pucchanti, abhidhammaṃ sutvā, abhidhamme ṭhatvā (pucchanti) vā. Vinayā pucchanti, vinayaṃ sutvā, vinaye ṭhatvā (pucchanti) vā. Dutiyā ca tatiyā ca. Abhidhammaṃ, abhidhammena vā. Vinayaṃ, vinayena vā. Evaṃ suttā, geyyā, gāthāya, veyyākaraṇā, udānā, itivuttakā, jātakā, abbhutadhammā, vedallā (Khu. vii, 111; VinA. i, 22; DA. i, 24)Khuddaka-nikāya · Vinaya-aṭṭhakathā · Dīgha-nikāya-aṭṭhakathā icc evamādi.

Kathane tvālope kammādhikaraṇesu: Abhidhammā kathayanti, abhidhammaṃ sutvā, abhidhamme ṭhatvā (kathayanti). Vinayā kathayanti, vinayaṃ sutvā, vinaye ṭhatvā (kathayanti). Dutiyā ca tatiyā ca. Abhidhammaṃ, abhidhammena vā. Vinayaṃ, vinayena vā. Evaṃ suttā, geyyā, gāthāya, veyyākaraṇā, udānā, itivuttakā, jātakā, abbhutadhammā, vedallā (Khu. vii, 111; VinA. i, 22; DA. i, 24)Khuddaka-nikāya · Vinaya-aṭṭhakathā · Dīgha-nikāya-aṭṭhakathā icc evamādi.

Thoke: Thokā muccanti;14Footnote: Muccati (Sī). appamattakā muccanti;15Footnote: Muccati (Sī). kicchā muccanti.16Footnote: Muccati (Sī). Tatiyā ca. Thokena, appamattakena, kicchena vā icc evamādi.

Akattari ca: Kammassa katattā upacitattā ussannattā vipulattā cakkhuviññāṇaṃ uppannaṃ hoti icc evamādi.

Caggahaṇena sesesu pi ye mayā nopadiṭṭhā apādānapayogikā, te payogavicakkhaṇehi yathāyogaṃ yojetabbā.

Far, near, measurement of distance and of time, elision of ‘tvā’, in connection with direction, comparison, abstinence, purity, liberation, cause, seclusion, measuring, in connection with the past, bondage, expression of quality, question, talk, little and no-agent.
In the meaning of far, in the meaning of near, in the measurement of distance, in the measurement of time, when there is elision of ‘tvā’, in connection with direction, in comparison, in connection with abstinence, in purity, in liberation, in the meaning of cause, in the meaning of seclusion, in measuring, in connection with the past, in the meaning of bondage, in the expression of quality, in question, in talk, in little and in no-agent; in these meanings and in these connections, that case has the name “ablative”.

First, (1) in the meaning of far:

  1. Kīvadūro ito Naḷakāragāmo (how far from here is the village of Naḷakāra?).
  2. Dūrato v’ āgamma (having come from far).
  3. Ārakā te moghapurisā imasmā dhammavinayā (those foolish men are far away from this Dhamma-Vinaya).
  4. Also the second and the third [inflection] [are used]. Dūraṃ gāmaṃ āgato, dūrena gāmena vā āgato ([he] came from a far village). Ārakā imaṃ dhammavinayaṃ, anena dhammavinayena vā (far from this Dhamma-Vinaya), etc.

(2) In the meaning of near:

  1. Antikaṃ gāmā (near the village); āsannaṃ gāmā (close to the village); samīpaṃ gāmā (next to the village).
  2. Samīpaṃ saddhammā (near the good Dhamma).
  3. Also the second and the third [inflection]. Antikaṃ gāmaṃ, antikaṃ gāmena vā. Āsannaṃ gāmaṃ, āsannaṃ gāmena vā. Samīpaṃ gāmaṃ, samīpaṃ gāmena vā. Samīpaṃ saddhammaṃ, samīpaṃ saddhammena vā, etc.

(3) In the measurement of distance:

  1. Ito Mathurāya catūsu yojanesu Saṅkassaṃ nāma nagaraṃ atthi; tattha bahū janā vasanti (the city called Saṅkassa is four yojanas from Mathurā; many people live there), etc.

(4) In the measurement of time:

  1. Ito bhikkhave ekanavutikappe Vipassī nāma Bhagavā loke udapādi (bhikkhus, ninety-one aeons from this one, the Blessed One Vipassī arose in the world).
  2. Ito tiṇṇaṃ māsānaṃ accayena parinibbāyissati (at the expiration of three months from now, [the Buddha] will attain Parinibbāna), etc.

(5) When there is elision of [a word ending in] ‘tvā’, [also used] in the accusative (kamma) and in the locative (adhikaraṇa):

  1. Pāsādā saṅkameyya (he should go from the mansion), pāsādaṃ abhiruhitvā (saṅkameyya) vā (or, having gone up the mansion, [he should go]).
  2. Pabbatā saṅkameyya (he should go from the mountain), pabbataṃ abhiruhitvā (saṅkameyya) vā (or, having climbed the mountain, [he should go]).
  3. Hatthikkhandhā saṅkameyya (he should descend from the back of the elephant), hatthikkhandhaṃ abhiruhitvā (saṅkameyya) vā (or, having climbed up the back of the elephant, [he should descend]).
  4. Āsanā vuṭṭhaheyya (he should get up from the seat), āsane nisīditvā (vuṭṭhaheyya) vā (or, having sat on the seat, [he should get up]), etc.

(6) In connection with [words that mean] direction:

  1. Avīcito yāva upari bhavaggam antare bahū sattanikāyā vasanti (many orders of beings live in the interval from Avīci up to the top of existence).
  2. Yato khemaṃ tato bhayaṃ (from where there is security, from there [arises] fear or danger).
  3. Puratthimato, dakkhiṇato, pacchimato, uttarato aggī pajjalanti (the fires blaze from the east, from the south, from the west, from the north).
  4. Yato assosuṃ bhagavantaṃ (from there they listened to the Blessed One).
  5. Uddhaṃ pādatalā adho kesamatthakā (upward from the soles of the feet, downward from the tips of the hair), etc.

(7) In comparison:

  1. Yato paṇītataro vā visiṭṭhataro vā natthi (there is nothing more exalted or more excellent than this).
  2. Also the sixth [inflection] [is used]. Channavutīnaṃ pāsaṇḍānaṃ dhammānaṃ pavaraṃ, yad idaṃ sugatavinayo (this Discipline of the Well-Gone One is better than the ninety-six sectarian Dhammas), etc.

(8) In connection with abstinence:

  1. Gāmadhammā vasaladhammā asaddhammā ārati virati paṭivirati ([one] refrains, abstains, desists completely from the way of the villages, from the way of the outcasts, from the bad dhamma).
  2. Pāṇātipātā veramaṇī (abstention from killing), etc.

(9) In purity:

  1. Lobhaniyehi dhammehi suddho asaṃsaṭṭho (pure and unmixed with the things that provoke attachment).
  2. Mātito ca pitito ca suddho asaṃsaṭṭho anupakuddho agarahito (pure, unmixed, blameless and irreproachable on the mother's side and on the father's side), etc.

(10) In liberation:

  1. Parimutto dukkhasmā ti vadāmi (I say “well freed from suffering”).
  2. Mutto ’smi Mārabandhanā (I am freed from the bondage of Māra).
  3. Na te muccanti maccunā (they are not freed from death), etc.

(11) In the meaning of cause:17Footnote: “Hetvatthe” means the word “hetu” as well as the words having the same meaning as “hetu”.

  1. Kasmā hetunā, kena hetunā, kissa hetunā (on account of what cause?, on account of which cause?, on account of the cause of what?).
  2. Kasmā nu tumhaṃ daharā na mīyare (why do your young ones not die?).
  3. Kasmā idh’ eva maraṇaṃ bhavissati (why will there be only death here?), etc.

(12) In the meaning of seclusion:

  1. Vivitto pāpakā dhammā (secluded from evil dhammas), vivicc eva kāmehi (secluded from sensual pleasures), vivicca akusalehi dhammehi (secluded from unwholesome dhammas), etc.

(13) In measuring:

  1. Dīghaso navavidatthiyo sugatavidatthiyā (in length, nine spans of the span of the Well-Gone One); pamāṇikā kāretabbā (it should be made according to the regular measurements); majjhimassa purisassa aḍḍhateḷasahatthā (twelve and a half cubits of the average man), etc.

(14) In connection with the past:

  1. Pubbe ’va sambodhā (before the Enlightenment), etc.

(15) In the meaning of bondage:

  1. Satasmā bandho naro (the man is imprisoned because of one hundred [of debt]).
  2. Also the third [inflection] [is used]. Satena bandho naro raññā iṇatthena (the man was imprisoned by the king because of a debt of one hundred), etc.

(16) In the expression of quality [both good and bad]:

  1. Puññāya sugatiṃ yanti (because of merit they go to a happy destination).
  2. Cāgāya vipulaṃ dhanaṃ (because of generosity, there is abundant wealth).
  3. Paññāya vimuttimano (because of wisdom, [he] is one whose mind is freed).
  4. Issariyāya janaṃ rakkhati rājā (because of his power, the king protects the people), etc.

(17) In questioning, when there is elision of [a word ending in] ‘tvā’, [also used] in the accusative (kamma) and in the locative (adhikaraṇa):

  1. Abhidhammā pucchanti (they ask about the Abhidhamma), Abhidhammaṃ sutvā, Abhidhamme ṭhatvā (pucchanti) vā (having listened to the Abhidhamma, or having stood on the Abhidhamma, they ask).
  2. Vinayā pucchanti (they ask about the Vinaya), vinayaṃ sutvā, vinaye ṭhatvā (pucchanti) vā (having listened to the Vinaya, or having stood on the Vinaya, they ask).
  3. Also the second and the third [inflection]. Abhidhammaṃ, abhidhammena vā. Vinayaṃ, vinayena vā. Likewise with the suttas, the geyyas, the gāthās, the veyyākaraṇas, the udānas, the itivuttakas, the jātakas, the abbhutadhammas and the vedallas, etc.

(18) In talking, when there is elision of [a word ending in] ‘tvā’, [also used] in the kamma (accusative) and in the adhikaraṇa (locative):

  1. Abhidhammā kathayanti (they talk about the Abhidhamma), abhidhammaṃ sutvā, abhidhamme ṭhatvā (kathayanti) (having listened to the Abhidhamma, or having stood on the Abhidhamma, they talk).
  2. Vinayā kathayanti (they talk about the Vinaya), vinayaṃ sutvā, vinaye ṭhatvā (kathayanti) (having listened to the Vinaya, or having stood on the Vinaya, they talk).
  3. Also the second and the third [inflection] [are used]. Abhidhammaṃ, abhidhammena vā. Vinayaṃ, vinayena vā. Likewise with the suttas, the geyyas, the gāthās, the veyyākaraṇas, the udānas, the itivuttakas, the jātakas, the abbhutadhammas and the vedallas, etc.

(19) In little:

  1. Thokā muccanti (they are liberated with little [effort]); appamattakā muccanti (they are liberated with not much); kicchā muccanti (they are liberated with difficulty).
  2. Also the third [inflection] [is used]. Thokena, appamattakena, kicchena vā, etc.

(20) And in no-agent:18Footnote: There are two agents: (1) the causative agent and (2) the pure agent. “Akattari” means non-causative agent.

  1. Kammassa katattā upacitattā ussannattā vipulattā cakkhuviññāṇaṃ uppannaṃ hoti (because of the kamma being done, accumulated, abundant and vast, eye-consciousness arises), etc.

By taking “ca”, also the remaining [examples] of the “apādāna” not shown by me should be constructed, as appropriate, by those who are skilled in giving examples.


14Footnote: Muccati (Sī).
15Footnote: Muccati (Sī).
16Footnote: Muccati (Sī).
17Footnote: “Hetvatthe” means the word “hetu” as well as the words having the same meaning as “hetu”.
18Footnote: There are two agents: (1) the causative agent and (2) the pure agent. “Akattari” means non-causative agent.
276Kaccāyana Sutta. 302Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Yassa dātukāmo rocate dhārayate vā taṃ sampadānaṃ (553)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Yassa + dātukāmo + rocate + dhārayate + vā + taṃ + sampadānaṃ = 7 words]

Yassa vā dātukāmo, yassa vā rocate, yassa vā dhārayate, taṃ kārakaṃ sampadānasaññaṃ hoti.

Samaṇassa cīvaraṃ dadāti; samaṇassa rocate saccaṃ; Devadattassa suvaṇṇacchattaṃ dhārayate Yaññadatto.

Sampadānam icc anena kvattho? Sampadāne catutthī.

Vā ti vikappanatthaṃ. Dhātu-nāmānaṃ payoge vā upasaggappayoge vā nipātappayoge vā sati atthavikappanatthaṃ vā ti padaṃ payujjati.

To whom [one] wants to give, to whom [something] is pleasing, or for whom [one] holds [something]: that is “sampadāna”.
To whom [one] wants to give, or to whom [something] is pleasing, or for whom [one] holds [something]: that case has the name “dative”.19Translator's note: From now on the term “sampadāna” is translated as “dative”.

  1. Samaṇassa cīvaraṃ dadāti ([he] gives the robe to the ascetic).
  2. Samaṇassa rocate saccaṃ (the truth is pleasing to the ascetic).
  3. Devadattassa suvaṇṇacchattaṃ dhārayate Yaññadatto (Yaññadatta holds the golden parasol for Devadatta).

What is the use of the name “sampadāna” (dative)? For the use of the name “sampadāna” in the sutta “Sampadāne catutthī” (§293). In the dative, the fourth [inflection].

“Vā” is in the sense of alternative (vikappana). When there is connection with roots and nouns, or connection with prefixes, or connection with particles, the word “vā” is employed as an alternative of meaning.


19Translator's note: From now on the term “sampadāna” is translated as “dative”.
277Kaccāyana Sutta. 303Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Silāgha-hanu-ṭhā-sapa-dhāra-piha-kudha-duh’-issosūya-rādh’-ikkha-paccāsuṇa-anupatigiṇa-pubbakatt’-ārocanattha-tadattha-tumatthālamattha-maññānādar’-appāṇini, gatyatthakammani, āsīsattha-sammuti-bhiyya-sattamyatthesu ca (554)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Silāgha-hanu-ṭhā-sapa-dhāra-piha-kudha-duha-issa-usūya-rādha-ikkha-paccāsuṇa-anupatigiṇa-pubbakattu-ārocanattha-tadattha-tumattha-alamattha-mañña-anādara-appāṇini + gatyatthakammani + āsīsattha-sammuti-bhiyya-sattamyatthesu + ca = 4 words]

Silāgha hanu ṭhā sapa dhāra piha kudha duha issa icc etesaṃ dhātūnaṃ payoge, usūyatthānañ ca payoge, rādh’-ikkhappayoge, paccāsuṇa-anu-pati-giṇānaṃ pubbakattari, ārocanatthe, tadatthe, tumatthe, alamatthe, maññatippayoge anādare appāṇini, gatyatthānaṃ dhātūnaṃ kammani, āsīsatthe ca sammuti bhiyya sattamyatthesu ca, taṃ kārakaṃ sampadānasaññaṃ hoti.

Silāghappayoge tāva: Buddhassa silāghate, Dhammassa silāghate, Saṃghassa silāghate; sakaṃ upajjhāyassa silāghate; tava silāghate, mama silāghate icc evamādi.

Hanuppayoge: Hanute tuyham eva, hanute mayham eva icc evamādi.

Ṭhāpayoge: Upatiṭṭheyya sakyaputtānaṃ vaḍḍhakī, bhikkhussa bhuñjantassa pānīyena vā vidhūpanena vā upatiṭṭheyya (Vin. ii, 345)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. ii, p. 345 bhikkhunī icc evamādi.

Sapappayoge: Tuyhaṃ sapate, mayhaṃ sapate icc evamādi.

Dhārappayoge: Suvaṇṇaṃ te dhārayate icc evamādi.

Pihappayoge: Buddhassa aññatitthiyā pihayanti; devā dassanakāmā te (Khu. vi, 186)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. vi, p. 186; yato icchāmi bhaddantassa; samiddhānaṃ pihayanti daliddā icc evamādi.

Kudha-duha-issa-usūyappayoge: Kodhayati Devadattassa; tassa kujjha Mahāvīra mā raṭṭhaṃ vinassa idaṃ (Khu. v, 99)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. v, p. 99.20Footnote: Nāyaṃ pāṭho Sīhaḷapotthakesu dissati. (This reading is not found in the Sinhalese manuscripts.) Duhayati disānaṃ megho. Titthiyā samaṇānaṃ issayanti guṇagiddhena; titthiyā samaṇānaṃ issayanti lābhagiddhena. Dujjanā guṇavantānaṃ usūyanti guṇagiddhena; kā usūyā vijānataṃ (Vin. iii, 55)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. iii, p. 55 icc evamādi.

Rādha ikkha icc etesaṃ dhātūnaṃ payoge yassa akathitassa pucchanaṃ kammavikkhyāpanatthañ ca, taṃ kārakaṃ sampadānasaññaṃ hoti, dutiyā ca.

Ārādho ’haṃ rañño, ārādho ’haṃ rājānaṃ;21Footnote: Ārādho me rañño, ārādho me rājānaṃ (Sī). ky āhaṃ ayyānaṃ aparajjhāmi (Vin. i, 248)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. i, p. 248; ky āhaṃ ayye aparajjhāmi. Cakkhuṃ janassa dassanāya taṃ viya maññe. Āyasmato Upālittherassa upasampadāpekkho Upatisso, āyasmantaṃ vā icc evamādi.

Paccāsuṇa-anupatigiṇānaṃ pubbakattari suṇotissa paccāyoge yassa22Footnote: “Yassā” ti padaṃ adhikan ti maññe, anantaravākye tassambandhatasaddassa abhāvā, tadatthassa ca idha anicchitattā, padarūpasiddhiyam pi taṃ natthi. (I consider the word “yassa” superfluous: in the immediate sentence the correlative “ta” related to it is lacking, and its meaning is not wanted here; nor is it in the Padarūpasiddhi.) kammuno pubbassa yo kattā, so sampadānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Bhagavā bhikkhū etad avoca.

Bhikkhū ti akathitakammam, etan ti kathitakammaṃ. Yassa23Footnote: “Yassā” ti padaṃ adhikan ti maññe, anantaravākye tassambandhatasaddassa abhāvā, tadatthassa ca idha anicchitattā, padarūpasiddhiyam pi taṃ natthi. (I consider the word “yassa” superfluous: in the immediate sentence the correlative “ta” related to it is lacking, and its meaning is not wanted here; nor is it in the Padarūpasiddhi.) kammuno pubbassa yo kattā, so “Bhagavā” ti24Footnote: Yassa -pa- kattāti so Bhagavā (K). “yo karoti sa kattā” ti suttavacanena kattusañño. Evaṃ yassa25Footnote: “Yassā” ti padaṃ adhikanti maññe. (I consider the word “yassa” superfluous.) kammuno pubbassa yo kattā, so sampadānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Te bhikkhū Bhagavato paccassosuṃ (D. ii, 9; M. i, 1; A. i, 1)Dīgha-nikāya · Majjhima-nikāya · Aṅguttara-nikāya. Āsuṇanti Buddhassa bhikkhū.

Giṇassa anu-patiyoge yassa26Footnote: “Yassā” ti padaṃ adhikanti maññe. (I consider the word “yassa” superfluous.) kammuno pubbassa yo kattā, so sampadānasañño hoti.

Taṃ yathā? Bhikkhu janaṃ dhammaṃ sāveti. Tassa bhikkhuno jano anugiṇāti; tassa bhikkhuno jano patigiṇāti.

Yo vadeti sa ‘kattā’ ti, Vuttaṃ ‘kamman’ ti vuccati. Yo paṭiggāhako tassa, ‘sampadānaṃ’ vijāniyā.

icc evamādi.

Ārocanatthe: Ārocayāmi vo bhikkhave (M. i, 339)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. i, p. 339; āmantayāmi vo bhikkhave (D. ii, 128)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 128; paṭivedayāmi vo bhikkhave (M. i, 339)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. i, p. 339. Ārocayāmi te mahārāja (S. i, 101)Saṃyutta-nikāya · vol. i, p. 101; āmantayāmi te mahārāja; paṭivedayāmi te mahārāja (S. i, 101)Saṃyutta-nikāya · vol. i, p. 101 icc evamādi.

Tadatthe: Ūnassa pāripūriyā taṃ cīvaraṃ nikkhipitabbaṃ. Buddhassa atthāya, Dhammassa atthāya, Saṃghassa atthāya, jīvitaṃ pariccajāmi icc evamādi.

Tumatthe: Lokānukampāya atthāya hitāya sukhāya devamanussānaṃ Buddho loke uppajjati (D. ii, 179; 181; M. i, 117; A. i, 21)Dīgha-nikāya · Majjhima-nikāya · Aṅguttara-nikāya. Bhikkhūnaṃ phāsuvihārāya vinayo paññatto (Vin. i, 24; v, 2)Vinaya-piṭaka icc evamādi.

Alamatthappayoge: Alam iti arahati paṭikkhittesu. Alaṃ me Buddho (Vin. i, 32)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. i, p. 32. Alaṃ me rajjaṃ (Khu. vi, 151)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. vi, p. 151. Alaṃ bhikkhu pattassa. Alaṃ mallo mallassa; arahati mallo mallassa. Paṭikkhitte: Alaṃ te rūpaṃ karaṇīyaṃ. Alaṃ me hiraññasuvaṇṇena icc evamādi.

Maññatippayoge anādare appāṇini: Kaṭṭhassa tuvaṃ maññe; kaliṅgarassa27Footnote: Kaḷiṅgarassa, kaḷaṅgarassa (K). tuvaṃ maññe.

Anādare ti kimatthaṃ? Suvaṇṇaṃ viya taṃ maññe.28Footnote: Suvaṇṇaṃ taṃ maññe (Rū). Suvaṇṇaṃ tvaṃ maññe (Sī).

Appāṇinī ti kimatthaṃ? Gadrabhaṃ tuvaṃ maññe icc evamādi.

Gatyatthakammani: Gāmassa pādena gato; nagarassa pādena gato; appo saggāya gacchati (Khu. i, 39)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 39, saggassa gamanena vā (Khu. i, 40)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 40; mūlāya paṭikasseyya saṃgho (Vin. iii, 442; iv, 114)Vinaya-piṭaka. Dutiyā ca. Gāmaṃ pādena gato, nagaraṃ pādena gato, appo saggaṃ gacchati, saggaṃ gamanena vā. Mūlaṃ paṭikasseyya saṃgho icc evamādi.

Āsīsatthe: Āyasmato dīghāyuko29Footnote: Dīghāyu (K). hotu; bhaddaṃ bhavato hotu; kusalaṃ bhavato hotu. Anāmayaṃ bhavato hotu; sukhaṃ bhavato hotu; svāgataṃ bhavato hotu; attho bhavato hotu; hitaṃ bhavato hotu icc evamādi.

Sammutippayoge: Aññatra saṃghasammutiyā bhikkhussa vippavatthuṃ na vaṭṭati. Sādhu sammuti me tassa Bhagavato dassanāya icc evamādi.

Bhiyyappayoge: Bhiyyoso mattāya30Footnote: Bhiyyosomattāya. D. i, 205; DA. i, 321; D. ii, 9; S, i, 23; SA. i, 63; A. i, 122; Khu. i, 170-1; UdānaA. 329. Siyyosomattāya. Vin. iv, 346. Iha tu atisayatthe nipāto yevā yaṃ “Bhiyyosomattāyā” ti (Mog.-pañcikā ii, 25)Moggallāna-pañcikā · vol. ii, p. 25Moggallāna-pañcikā · vol. ii, p. 25. (But here “Bhiyyosomattāya” is only a particle with intensive meaning.) Sad. Sutta, 125-6; 175-piṭṭhesu pi passitabbaṃ. (See also pages 125-6 and 175 of the Saddanīti.) icc evamādi.

Sattamyatthe: Tuyhañ c’ assa āvikaromi; tassa me Sakko pātur ahosi icc evamādi.

Atthaggahaṇena bahūsu akkharappayogesu dissati.

Taṃ yathā? Upamaṃ te karissāmi (D. ii, 259; M. i, 203)Dīgha-nikāya · Majjhima-nikāya, dhammaṃ vo desessāmi (M. iii, 86)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. iii, p. 86.

Sāratthe31Footnote: Sādaratthe (Sī). Sārattho nāma uttamattho, cintāpanattho vā (Nyā; Sad. 126-piṭṭhe). (“Sārattha” means the supreme meaning, or the meaning that makes one think.) ca: Desetu bhante Bhagavā dhammaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ. Tassa phāsu vihārāya hoti. Etassa pahiṇeyya.32Footnote: Phāsuvihārāya hotu (K). Yathā no Bhagavā byākareyya, tathā pi tesaṃ byākarissāma. Kappati samaṇānaṃ āyogo. Amhākaṃ maṇinā attho (Vin. i, 220)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. i, p. 220. Kim attho me buddhena. Seyyo me attho. Bahūpakārā bhante Mahāpajāpatigotamī Bhagavato (M. iii, 290)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. iii, p. 290. Bahūpakārā bhikkhave mātāpitaro puttānaṃ (Khu. i, 269; A. i, 131)Khuddaka-nikāya · Aṅguttara-nikāya icc evamādi.

Sesesu akkharappayogesu pi aññe pi payogā payogavicakkhaṇehi yojetabbā.

Caggahaṇaṃ vikappanatthavāggahaṇānukaḍḍhanatthaṃ.33Footnote: Anekatthattā nipātānaṃ, caggahaṇassa ca nipātattā tapphalaṃ assento casaddaggahaṇaṃ vikappanatthavāggahaṇanukaḍḍhanatthanti āha (Nyā). Kaccāyane pana “sattamyatthesu cā” ti casaddaggahaṇaṃ vikappanatthavāggahaṇānukaḍḍhanattham eva. Sad. sutta. 126-piṭṭhe. (Since particles have many meanings and the “ca” taken is a particle, showing its fruit he says that taking the word “ca” is for the dragging of “vā” with the meaning of alternative (Nyāsa). In Kaccāyana, in “sattamyatthesu ca”, taking the word “ca” is only for the dragging of “vā” with the meaning of alternative.) Ye keci saddā sampadānappayogikā mayā nopadiṭṭhā, tesaṃ gahaṇatthaṃ idha vikappīyati vā saddo.34Footnote: Iti vikappayati (Sī).

Taṃ yathā? Bhikkhusaṃghassa pabhū ayaṃ Bhagavā. Desassa pabhū ayaṃ rājā. Khettassa pabhū ayaṃ gahapati. Araññassa pabhū ayaṃ luddako icc evamādi. Kvaci dutiyā tatiyā pañcamī chaṭṭhī sattamyatthesu ca.35Footnote: Dutiyā pañcamī chaṭṭhī sattamyatthesu (Sī).

‘Silāgha’, ‘hanu’, ‘ṭhā’, ‘sapa’, ‘dhāra’, ‘piha’, ‘kudha’, ‘duha’, ‘issa’ and ‘usūya’, ‘rādha’ and ‘ikkha’, in the former subject of ‘paccāsuṇa’ and ‘anupatigiṇa’, in the meaning of announcing, in the purpose of that, in the meaning of ‘tuṃ’, in the meaning of “alaṃ”, with ‘mañña’ in disrespect and in a non-living being, in the object [of roots] having the meaning of going, and in the meaning of benediction, with “sammuti”, with “bhiyya” and in the meanings of the seventh [inflection], also [there is “dative”].
In connection with these roots: ‘silāgha’ (praising), ‘hanu’ (deceiving/removing), ‘ṭhā’ (standing), ‘sapa’ (swearing/insulting), ‘dhāra’ (holding/owing), ‘piha’ (liking/loving), ‘kudha’ (being angry), ‘duha’ (wishing to harm), ‘issa’ (envying), in connection with [roots] having the meaning of ‘usūya’ (showing anger), in connection with [the roots] ‘rādha’ (pleasing) and ‘ikkha’ (seeing), in the subject of the previous [sentence] [when] the root ‘su’ (hearing), preceded by ‘pati’ and ‘ā’, and the root ‘ge’ (making sound), preceded by ‘anu’ and ‘pati’, [are used]; in the meaning of announcing; in the purpose of that; in the meaning of ‘tuṃ’; in the meaning of “alaṃ”; in connection with [the root] ‘mana’ in [the expression of] disrespect and towards a non-living being; in the object of roots having the meaning of going; in the meaning of benediction; [in connection] with “sammuti” and “bhiyya”; and in the meaning of the locative: that case has the name “dative”.

First, (1) in connection with [the root] ‘silāgha’ (praising):

  1. Buddhassa silāghate, Dhammassa silāghate, Saṃghassa silāghate ([one] praises the Buddha, praises the Dhamma, praises the Saṅgha).
  2. Sakaṃ upajjhāyassa silāghate ([he] praises his own preceptor).
  3. Tava silāghate, mama silāghate ([he] praises you, praises me), etc.

(2) In connection with [the root] ‘hanu’ (deceiving/removing):

  1. Hanute tuyham eva, hanute mayham eva ([he] lies to you, lies to me), etc.

(3) In connection with [the root] ‘ṭhā’ (standing):

  1. Upatiṭṭheyya Sakyaputtānaṃ vaḍḍhakī (the carpenter should attend to the sons of the Sakyas).
  2. Bhikkhussa bhuñjantassa pānīyena vā vidhūpanena vā upatiṭṭheyya bhikkhunī ([if] a bhikkhunī should attend with water or with a fan to a bhikkhu who is eating…), etc.

(4) In connection with [the root] ‘sapa’ (swearing [to tell the truth]):

  1. Tuyhaṃ sapate, mayhaṃ sapate ([he] swears to you, swears to me), etc.

(5) In connection with [the root] ‘dhāra’ (holding/owing):

  1. Suvaṇṇaṃ te dhārayate ([he] owes you gold), etc.

(6) In connection with [the root] ‘piha’ (liking/loving):

  1. Buddhassa aññatitthiyā pihayanti (the followers of other teachings like the Buddha).
  2. Devā dassanakāmā te (the deities wish to see you).
  3. Yato icchāmi bhaddantassa (because I want the venerable).
  4. Samiddhānaṃ pihayanti daliddā (the poor like the rich), etc.

(7) In connection with [the roots] ‘kudha’ (being angry), ‘duha’ (damaging), ‘issa’ (envying) and ‘usūya’ (showing anger):

  1. Kodhayati Devadattassa ([he] is angry with Devadatta).
  2. Tassa kujjha Mahāvīra mā raṭṭhaṃ vinassa idaṃ (be angry with him, Great Hero; do not let this country be destroyed).
  3. Duhayati disānaṃ megho (the storm destroys the countries).
  4. Titthiyā samaṇānaṃ issayanti guṇagiddhena; titthiyā samaṇānaṃ issayanti lābhagiddhena (because of greed for honor, the followers of [other] teachings are jealous of the ascetics; because of greed for gain, the followers of [other] teachings are jealous of the ascetics).
  5. Dujjanā guṇavantānaṃ usūyanti guṇagiddhena (because of greed for honor, bad people find fault with the virtuous); kā usūyā vijānataṃ (what is the criticism of those who know?), etc.

(8) In connection with the roots ‘rādha’ (pleasing) and ‘ikkha’ (seeing), the one who has not been spoken of and about whom one asks, and for the purpose of making known the action: that case has the name “dative”; also the second [inflection] [is used].

  1. Ārādho ’haṃ rañño (I like the king), ārādho ’haṃ rājānaṃ.
  2. Ky āhaṃ ayyānaṃ aparajjhāmi (what have I done wrong to the venerables?); ky āhaṃ ayye aparajjhāmi.
  3. Cakkhuṃ janassa dassanāya taṃ viya maññe (I consider the eye to see people just as I consider you [= I regard you as the eye]).
  4. Āyasmato Upālittherassa upasampadāpekkho Upatisso (the Venerable Upatissa wishes the higher ordination from the Venerable Upāli), āyasmantaṃ vā, etc.

(9) In the former subject of ‘paccāsuṇa’ and ‘anupatigiṇa’: when the root ‘su’ (hearing) is in connection with ‘paccā’ [= ‘pati’ + ‘ā’], whatever is the subject of the previous object has the name “dative”.

As what? Bhagavā bhikkhū etad avoca (the Blessed One said this to the bhikkhus).

[Here] “bhikkhū” is the indirect object (akathitakamma) and “etaṃ” is the direct object (kathitakamma). The subject of the previous object (“etaṃ”), “Bhagavā”, has the name “kattu” by the sutta “Yo karoti sa kattā” (§281). Thus, whatever is the subject of the previous object has the name “dative”.

As what?

  1. Te bhikkhū Bhagavato paccassosuṃ (those bhikkhus replied to the Blessed One).
  2. Āsuṇanti Buddhassa bhikkhū (the bhikkhus listen to the Buddha).

(10) In connection with ‘anu’ and ‘pati’ of the root ‘ge’ (making sound), whatever is the subject of the previous object has the name “dative”.

As what? Bhikkhu janaṃ dhammaṃ sāveti (the bhikkhu makes the people listen to the Dhamma).

  1. Tassa bhikkhuno jano anugiṇāti (the people cheer that bhikkhu).
  2. Tassa bhikkhuno jano patigiṇāti (the people approve that bhikkhu).

The one who speaks, that is the “subject” (kattā); What is said is called “object” (kamma); The one who receives it should be understood as “dative”.

And so on.

(11) In the meaning of announcing:

  1. Ārocayāmi vo bhikkhave; āmantayāmi vo bhikkhave; paṭivedayāmi vo bhikkhave (I announce to you, bhikkhus; I inform you, bhikkhus; I declare to you, bhikkhus).
  2. Ārocayāmi te mahārāja; āmantayāmi te mahārāja; paṭivedayāmi te mahārāja (I announce to you, great king; I inform you, great king; I declare to you, great king), etc.

(12) In the purpose of that: That robe should be put aside for the sake of fulfilling that which is deficient. For the sake of the Buddha, for the sake of the Dhamma, for the sake of the Saṅgha I give up [my] life.

(13) In the meaning of ‘tuṃ’:

  1. Lokānukampāya atthāya hitāya sukhāya devamanussānaṃ Buddho loke uppajjati (the Buddha appears in the world out of compassion for the world, for the welfare, for the benefit and for the happiness of devas and humans).
  2. Bhikkhūnaṃ phāsuvihārāya vinayo paññatto (the Vinaya was established for the sake of the living in comfort of the bhikkhus), etc.

(14) In connection with [words that have] the meaning of “alaṃ”: “Alaṃ” means worthy (arahati) and rejection (paṭikkhitta).

  1. Alaṃ me Buddho (the Buddha is worthy for me).
  2. Alaṃ me rajjaṃ (the kingdom is worthy for me).
  3. Alaṃ bhikkhu pattassa (the bhikkhu is worthy of the bowl).
  4. Alaṃ mallo mallassa; arahati mallo mallassa (one wrestler is a match for another wrestler; one wrestler is worthy of another wrestler).
In the [meaning of] rejection
  1. Alaṃ te rūpaṃ karaṇīyaṃ (matter is nothing to you). Alaṃ me hiraññasuvaṇṇena (I do not need silver and gold), etc.

(15) In connection with the root ‘mana’, in [the expression of] disrespect and towards a non-living being:

  1. Kaṭṭhassa tuvaṃ maññe (I consider you as a log).
  2. Kaliṅgarassa tuvaṃ maññe (I consider you as a rotten piece of wood).

What is the purpose of saying “anādare” (disrespect)? [This sutta does not apply when there is no disrespect, as in:] Suvaṇṇaṃ viya taṃ maññe (I consider you as gold).

What is the purpose of saying “appāṇini” (non-living being)? [This sutta does not apply when there is a living being, as in:] Gadrabhaṃ tuvaṃ maññe (I consider you an ass). And so on.

(16) In the object of [roots that have the] meaning of going:

  1. Gāmassa pādena gato (gone to the village on foot); nagarassa pādena gato (gone to the city on foot).
  2. Appo saggāya gacchati (few go to heaven), saggassa gamanena vā (or by going to heaven).
  3. Mūlāya paṭikasseyya saṃgho (the Saṅgha should draw [him] back to the beginning).
  4. Also the second [inflection] [is used]. Gāmaṃ pādena gato, nagaraṃ pādena gato, appo saggaṃ gacchati, saggaṃ gamanena vā. Mūlaṃ paṭikasseyya saṃgho [the same examples], etc.

(17) In the meaning of benediction:

  1. Āyasmato dīghāyuko hotu (may there be long life for the venerable).
  2. Bhaddaṃ bhavato hotu (may there be good for you); kusalaṃ bhavato hotu (may there be health for you); anāmayaṃ bhavato hotu (may you be free from disease); sukhaṃ bhavato hotu (may there be happiness for you); svāgataṃ bhavato hotu (may you be welcome); attho bhavato hotu (may there be welfare for you); hitaṃ bhavato hotu (may there be benefit for you), etc.

(18) In connection with “sammuti” (consent):

  1. Aññatra saṃghasammutiyā bhikkhussa vippavatthuṃ na vaṭṭati (except with the consent of the Saṅgha, it is not proper for a bhikkhu to stay away [from the robe]).
  2. Sādhu sammuti me tassa Bhagavato dassanāya (it is good the consent for me to see that Blessed One), etc.

(19) In connection with “bhiyya” (more):

  1. Bhiyyoso mattāya (more than the measure), etc.

(20) In the meaning of the seventh [inflection]:

  1. Tuyhañ c’ assa āvikaromi (and I declare it to you).
  2. Tassa me Sakko pātur ahosi (Sakka manifested to that [which is] me), etc.

(21) By taking “attha”, many examples are found.

As what?

  1. Upamaṃ te karissāmi (I will give you a simile).
  2. Dhammaṃ vo desessāmi (I will preach the Dhamma to you).

(22) And in the meaning of the root ‘sāra’ (going or thinking):

  1. Desetu bhante Bhagavā dhammaṃ bhikkhūnaṃ (venerable sir, let the Blessed One preach the Dhamma to the bhikkhus).
  2. Tassa phāsu vihārāya hoti (for his living in comfort).
  3. Etassa pahiṇeyya (it should be sent to him).
  4. Yathā no Bhagavā byākareyya, tathā pi tesaṃ byākarissāma (just as the Blessed One may explain to us, in the same way we will explain to them).
  5. Kappati samaṇānaṃ āyogo (is the cloth belt allowable for the ascetics?).
  6. Amhākaṃ maṇinā attho (we need the jewel).
  7. Kim attho me Buddhena (what is the use of the Buddha to me?).
  8. Seyyo me attho (the benefit is the best for me).
  9. Bahūpakārā bhante Mahāpajāpatigotamī Bhagavato (venerable sir, Mahāpajāpatigotamī has been very helpful to the Blessed One).
  10. Bahūpakārā bhikkhave mātāpitaro puttānaṃ (bhikkhus, the mother and father are very helpful to the sons), etc.

Also in the remaining constructions of words, other examples should be constructed by those who are skilled in giving examples.

Taking “ca” is for the dragging of “vā”, which has the meaning of alternative (vikappana). Here the word “vā” is employed to drag (include) whatever words with the function of the dative that have not been shown by me.

As what?

  1. Bhikkhusaṃghassa pabhū ayaṃ Bhagavā (this Blessed One is the lord of the Saṅgha of bhikkhus).
  2. Desassa pabhū ayaṃ rājā (this king is the lord of the country).
  3. Khettassa pabhū ayaṃ gahapati (this householder is the lord of the field).
  4. Araññassa pabhū ayaṃ luddako (this hunter is the lord of the forest), etc.

Sometimes [it is] also [used] in the meaning of the second, the third, the fifth, the sixth and the seventh [inflection].


20Footnote: Nāyaṃ pāṭho Sīhaḷapotthakesu dissati. (This reading is not found in the Sinhalese manuscripts.)
21Footnote: Ārādho me rañño, ārādho me rājānaṃ (Sī).
22Footnote: “Yassā” ti padaṃ adhikan ti maññe, anantaravākye tassambandhatasaddassa abhāvā, tadatthassa ca idha anicchitattā, padarūpasiddhiyam pi taṃ natthi. (I consider the word “yassa” superfluous: in the immediate sentence the correlative “ta” related to it is lacking, and its meaning is not wanted here; nor is it in the Padarūpasiddhi.)
23Footnote: “Yassā” ti padaṃ adhikan ti maññe, anantaravākye tassambandhatasaddassa abhāvā, tadatthassa ca idha anicchitattā, padarūpasiddhiyam pi taṃ natthi. (I consider the word “yassa” superfluous: in the immediate sentence the correlative “ta” related to it is lacking, and its meaning is not wanted here; nor is it in the Padarūpasiddhi.)
24Footnote: Yassa -pa- kattāti so Bhagavā (K).
25Footnote: “Yassā” ti padaṃ adhikanti maññe. (I consider the word “yassa” superfluous.)
26Footnote: “Yassā” ti padaṃ adhikanti maññe. (I consider the word “yassa” superfluous.)
27Footnote: Kaḷiṅgarassa, kaḷaṅgarassa (K).
28Footnote: Suvaṇṇaṃ taṃ maññe (Rū). Suvaṇṇaṃ tvaṃ maññe (Sī).
29Footnote: Dīghāyu (K).
30Footnote: Bhiyyosomattāya. D. i, 205; DA. i, 321; D. ii, 9; S, i, 23; SA. i, 63; A. i, 122; Khu. i, 170-1; UdānaA. 329. Siyyosomattāya. Vin. iv, 346. Iha tu atisayatthe nipāto yevā yaṃ “Bhiyyosomattāyā” ti (Mog.-pañcikā ii, 25)Moggallāna-pañcikā · vol. ii, p. 25. (But here “Bhiyyosomattāya” is only a particle with intensive meaning.) Sad. Sutta, 125-6; 175-piṭṭhesu pi passitabbaṃ. (See also pages 125-6 and 175 of the Saddanīti.)
31Footnote: Sādaratthe (Sī). Sārattho nāma uttamattho, cintāpanattho vā (Nyā; Sad. 126-piṭṭhe). (“Sārattha” means the supreme meaning, or the meaning that makes one think.)
32Footnote: Phāsuvihārāya hotu (K).
33Footnote: Anekatthattā nipātānaṃ, caggahaṇassa ca nipātattā tapphalaṃ assento casaddaggahaṇaṃ vikappanatthavāggahaṇanukaḍḍhanatthanti āha (Nyā). Kaccāyane pana “sattamyatthesu cā” ti casaddaggahaṇaṃ vikappanatthavāggahaṇānukaḍḍhanattham eva. Sad. sutta. 126-piṭṭhe. (Since particles have many meanings and the “ca” taken is a particle, showing its fruit he says that taking the word “ca” is for the dragging of “vā” with the meaning of alternative (Nyāsa). In Kaccāyana, in “sattamyatthesu ca”, taking the word “ca” is only for the dragging of “vā” with the meaning of alternative.)
34Footnote: Iti vikappayati (Sī).
35Footnote: Dutiyā pañcamī chaṭṭhī sattamyatthesu (Sī).
278Kaccāyana Sutta. 320Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Yo ’dhāro tam okāsaṃ (572-3)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Yo + ādhāro + taṃ + okāsaṃ = 4 words]

Yo ādhāro, taṃ okāsasaññaṃ hoti. Sv ādhāro catubbidho: byāpiko, opasilesiko, vesayiko sāmīpiko cā ti.

Tattha byāpiko tāva: Jalesu khīraṃ tiṭṭhati, tilesu telaṃ, ucchūsu raso.

Opasilesiko: Pariyaṅke rājā seti; āsane upaviṭṭho saṃgho.

Vesayiko: Bhūmīsu manussā caranti; antalikkhe vāyū vāyanti; ākāse sakuṇā pakkhandanti.36Footnote: Pakkhanti (K).

Sāmīpiko: Vane hatthino caranti; gaṅgāyaṃ ghoso tiṭṭhati; vaje gāvo duhanti; Sāvatthiyaṃ viharati Jetavane (A. i, 1; S. i, 1)Aṅguttara-nikāya · Saṃyutta-nikāya.

Okāsam icc anena kvattho? Okāse sattamī.

That which is the receptacle, that is “okāsa”.37Translator's note: From now on the term “okāsa” is translated as “locative”.
That which is a receptacle has the name “locative”.
That receptacle is fourfold: (1) pervading (byāpika), (2) close contact (opasilesika), (3) domain (vesayika) and (4) nearness (sāmīpika).

Here, first, (1) pervading (byāpika):

  1. Jalesu khīraṃ tiṭṭhati (milk exists in the waters), tilesu telaṃ (oil, in the sesame), ucchūsu raso (juice, in the sugar canes).

(2) Close contact (opasilesika):

  1. Pariyaṅke rājā seti (the king lies on the couch).
  2. Āsane upaviṭṭho saṃgho (the Saṅgha is seated on the seat).

(3) Domain (vesayika):

  1. Bhūmīsu manussā caranti (humans walk on the earth).
  2. Antalikkhe vāyū vāyanti (the winds blow in the sky).
  3. Ākāse sakuṇā pakkhandanti (the birds fly in the space).

(4) Nearness (sāmīpika):

  1. Vane hatthino caranti (the elephants roam near the forest).
  2. Gaṅgāyaṃ ghoso tiṭṭhati (the village of cowherds is near the Ganges).
  3. Vaje gāvo duhanti (they milk the cows near the pen).
  4. Sāvatthiyaṃ viharati Jetavane ([the Blessed One] dwells near Sāvatthī, in Jeta's Grove).

What is the use of the name “okāsa” (locative)? For the use of the name “okāsa” in the sutta “Okāse sattamī” (§302). In the locative, the seventh [inflection].


36Footnote: Pakkhanti (K).
37Translator's note: From now on the term “okāsa” is translated as “locative”.
279Kaccāyana Sutta. 292Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Yena vā kayirate taṃ karaṇaṃ (552)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Yena + vā + kayirate + taṃ + karaṇaṃ = 5 words]

Yena vā kayirate, yena vā passati, yena vā suṇāti, taṃ kārakaṃ karaṇasaññaṃ hoti.

Dattena vīhiṃ lunāti; vāsiyā kaṭṭhaṃ tacchati; pharasunā rukkhaṃ chindati; kudālena pathaviṃ38Footnote: Āvāṭaṃ (Sī). khaṇati; satthena kammaṃ karoti. Cakkhunā rūpaṃ passati (D. ii, 269)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 269; sotena saddaṃ suṇāti (D. ii, 269)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 269.

Karaṇam icc anena kvattho? Karaṇe tatiyā.

By means of this [one] does, that is “karaṇa”.39Translator's note: From now on the term “karaṇa” is translated as “instrumental”.
By means of this [one] does, by means of this [one] sees, by means of this [one] hears: that case has the name “instrumental”.

  1. Dattena vīhiṃ lunāti ([he] cuts the paddy with the sickle).
  2. Vāsiyā kaṭṭhaṃ tacchati (chips the timber with the adze).
  3. Pharasunā rukkhaṃ chindati (cuts the tree with the hatchet).
  4. Kudālena pathaviṃ khaṇati (digs the earth with the spade).
  5. Satthena kammaṃ karoti (does the work with the knife).
  6. Cakkhunā rūpaṃ passati (sees a form with the eye).
  7. Sotena saddaṃ suṇāti (hears the sound with the ear).

What is the use of the name “karaṇa” (instrumental)? For the use of the name “karaṇa” in the sutta “Karaṇe tatiyā” (§286). In the instrumental, the third [inflection].


38Footnote: Āvāṭaṃ (Sī).
39Translator's note: From now on the term “karaṇa” is translated as “instrumental”.
280Kaccāyana Sutta. 285Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Yaṃ karoti taṃ kammaṃ (551)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Yaṃ + karoti + taṃ + kammaṃ = 4 words]

Yaṃ vā karoti, yaṃ vā passati, yaṃ vā suṇāti, taṃ kārakaṃ kammasaññaṃ hoti.

Chattaṃ karoti; rathaṃ karoti; rūpaṃ passati (D. ii, 269)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 269; saddaṃ suṇāti (D. ii, 269)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 269; kaṇṭakaṃ maddati; visaṃ gilati.

Kammam icc anena kvattho? Kammatthe dutiyā.

[One] does that, that is “kamma”.40Translator's note: From now on the term “kamma” is translated as “object”.
Does that, sees that, hears that: that case has the name “object”.

  1. Chattaṃ karoti ([he] makes an umbrella).
  2. Rathaṃ karoti (makes a chariot).
  3. Rūpaṃ passati (sees a form).
  4. Saddaṃ suṇāti (hears a sound).
  5. Kaṇṭakaṃ maddati (steps on a thorn).
  6. Visaṃ gilati (swallows poison).

What is the use of the name “kamma” (object)? For the use of the name “kamma” in the sutta “Kammatthe dutiyā” (§297). In the meaning of the object, the second [inflection].


40Translator's note: From now on the term “kamma” is translated as “object”.
281Kaccāyana Sutta. 294Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Yo karoti sa kattā (548)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Yo + karoti + so + kattā = 4 words]

Yo karoti, so kattusañño hoti.

Ahinā daṭṭho naro; garuḷena hato nāgo. Buddhena jito Māro; Upaguttena Māro bandho.41Footnote: Baddho (K).

Kattu icc anena kvattho? Kattari ca.

The one who does, he is “kattā”.42Translator's note: From now on the term “kattā” is translated as “subject” or “agent”.
The one who does has the name “subject”.

  1. Ahinā daṭṭho naro (the man is bitten by the snake).
  2. Garuḷena hato nāgo (the serpent was killed by the garuḷa).
  3. Buddhena jito Māro (Māra was defeated by the Buddha).
  4. Upaguttena Māro bandho (Māra was bound by Upagutta).

What is the use of the name “kattu” (subject)? For the use of the name “kattu” in the sutta “Kattari ca” (§288). And in the subject [the third inflection].


41Footnote: Baddho (K).
42Translator's note: From now on the term “kattā” is translated as “subject” or “agent”.
282Kaccāyana Sutta. 295Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Yo kāreti sa hetu (550)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Yo + kāreti + so + hetu = 4 words]

Yo kattāraṃ kāreti, so hetusañño hoti, kattā ca.

So puriso taṃ purisaṃ kammaṃ kāreti; so puriso tena purisena kammaṃ kāreti; so puriso tassa purisassa kammaṃ kāreti. Evaṃ hāreti, pāṭheti, pāceti, dhāreti.

Hetu icc anena kvattho? Dhātūhi ṇe-ṇaya-ṇāpe-ṇāpayā kāritāni hetvatthe.

The one who causes to do, he is “hetu”.43Translator's note: From now on the term “hetu” is translated as “cause”.
The one who causes the doer to do has the name “cause”, and also “subject”.

  1. So puriso taṃ purisaṃ kammaṃ kāreti (the man causes the man to do the work); so puriso tena purisena kammaṃ kāreti; so puriso tassa purisassa kammaṃ kāreti. (The object of the causative can also be in the third inflection, “tena purisena”, and in the sixth inflection, “tassa purisassa”.)
  2. Thus with “hāreti”, to cause to carry; “pāṭheti”, to cause to read; “pāceti”, to cause to cook; “dhāreti”, to hold.

What is the use of the name “hetu” (cause)? For the use of the name “hetu” in the sutta “Dhātūhi ṇe-ṇaya-ṇāpe-ṇāpayā kāritāni hetvatthe” (§438). After roots, the causatives ‘ṇe’, ‘ṇaya’, ‘ṇāpe’ and ‘ṇāpaya’ [are used] in the meaning of cause.


43Translator's note: From now on the term “hetu” is translated as “cause”.
283Kaccāyana Sutta. 316Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Yassa vā pariggaho taṃ sāmī (575)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta44Footnote: “Vā” is used to include ‘tabba’, the root ‘rūja’, etc. See Rūpasiddhi, page 168.
[Yassa + vā + pariggaho + taṃ + sāmī = 5 words]

Yassa vā pariggaho, taṃ sāmīsaññaṃ hoti.

Tassa bhikkhuno paṭivīso;45Footnote: Paṭivīso ca koṭṭhāso (Abhidhā. 485-gāthā). (“Paṭivīsa” is a portion.) bhikkhuno patto; tassa bhikkhuno cīvaraṃ; attano mukhaṃ.

Sāmī icc anena kvattho? Sāmismiṃ chaṭṭhī.

The possession of that, this is “sāmī”.
The possession of that, this has the name “possessive”.46Translator's note: From now on the term “sāmī” is translated as “possessive” (also genitive).

  1. Tassa bhikkhuno paṭivīso (the portion of that bhikkhu).
  2. Bhikkhuno patto (the bowl of the bhikkhu).
  3. Tassa bhikkhuno cīvaraṃ (the robe of that bhikkhu).
  4. Attano mukhaṃ (the mouth of oneself).

What is the use of the name “sāmī” (possessive)? For the use of the name “sāmī” in the sutta “Sāmismiṃ chaṭṭhī” (§301). In the possessive, the sixth [inflection].


44Footnote: “Vā” is used to include ‘tabba’, the root ‘rūja’, etc. See Rūpasiddhi, page 168.
45Footnote: Paṭivīso ca koṭṭhāso (Abhidhā. 485-gāthā). (“Paṭivīsa” is a portion.)
46Translator's note: From now on the term “sāmī” is translated as “possessive” (also genitive).
284Kaccāyana Sutta. 283Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Liṅgatthe paṭhamā (577)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Liṅga-atthe + paṭhamā = 2 words]

Liṅgatthābhidhānamatte paṭhamāvibhatti hoti.

Puriso, purisā, eko, dve, ca, vā, he, ahe, re, are.

In the meaning of the base, the first [inflection].47Translator's note: We translate “attha” as “meaning”, as in the rest of the project.
In just denoting the meaning of the base there is the first inflection.

  1. Puriso (man), purisā (men), eko (one), dve (two), ca (and), vā (or), he (hey), ahe (oh), re (heigh), are (halloo).

47Translator's note: We translate “attha” as “meaning”, as in the rest of the project.
285Kaccāyana Sutta. 70Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Ālapane ca (578)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Ālapane + ca = 2 words]

Ālapanatthādhike liṅgatthābhidhānamatte ca paṭhamāvibhatti hoti.

Bho purisa, bhavanto purisā; bho rāja, bhavanto rājāno; he sakhe, he sakhino.

Also in the vocative.
When the meaning of the vocative is added to just denoting the meaning of the base, there is also the first inflection.

  1. Bho purisa (oh man), bhavanto purisā (oh men).
  2. Bho rāja (oh king), bhavanto rājāno (oh kings).
  3. He sakhe (hey friend), he sakhino (hey friends).
286Kaccāyana Sutta. 291Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Karaṇe tatiyā (591)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Karaṇe + tatiyā = 2 words]

Karaṇakārake tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Agginā kuṭiṃ jhāpeti; manasā ce paduṭṭhena (Khu. i, 13)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 13; manasā ce pasannena (Khu. i, 13)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 13; kāyena kammaṃ karoti (M. ii, 77)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 77.

In the instrument, the third [inflection].
In the instrumental case there is the third inflection.

  1. Agginā kuṭiṃ jhāpeti ([he] burns the hut with fire).
  2. Manasā ce paduṭṭhena (if with a corrupted mind).
  3. Manasā ce pasannena (if with a pure mind).
  4. Kāyena kammaṃ karoti (does the work with the body).
287Kaccāyana Sutta. 296Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Sahādiyoge ca (592)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Saha-ādiyoge + ca = 2 words]

Sahādiyogatthe48Footnote: Sahādīnaṃ yoge sati, tadatthe ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti -pa- ayaṃ pan’ ettha padacchedo “sahādiyoge atthe cā” ti (Nyā). (When there is connection with “saha” and others, and also in the meaning of these, there is the third inflection… and here the word division is “sahādiyoge atthe ca” [Nyāsa].) ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Sahā ’pi Gaggena saṃgho uposathaṃ kareyya (Vin. iii, 166)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. iii, p. 166, vinā pi Gaggena (Vin. iii, 166)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. iii, p. 166, mahatā bhikkhusaṃghena saddhiṃ (Vin. iii, 45; D. i, 1; ii, 81)Vinaya-piṭaka · Dīgha-nikāya; sahassena samaṃ mitā (S. i, 18)Saṃyutta-nikāya · vol. i, p. 18.

Also with “saha” and others.
In connection with [words] that have the meaning of “saha” and others there is also the third inflection.

  1. Sahā ’pi Gaggena saṃgho uposathaṃ kareyya, vinā pi Gaggena (the Saṅgha should do the uposatha with Gagga or without Gagga).
  2. Mahatā bhikkhusaṃghena saddhiṃ (together with the great Community of bhikkhus).
  3. Sahassena samaṃ mitā (measured evenly with one thousand).

48Footnote: Sahādīnaṃ yoge sati, tadatthe ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti -pa- ayaṃ pan’ ettha padacchedo “sahādiyoge atthe cā” ti (Nyā). (When there is connection with “saha” and others, and also in the meaning of these, there is the third inflection… and here the word division is “sahādiyoge atthe ca” [Nyāsa].)
288Kaccāyana Sutta. 293Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Kattari ca (594)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Kattari + ca = 2 words]

Kattari ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Raññā hato poso; yakkhena dinno varo; ahinā daṭṭho naro.

Also in the subject.
In the subject there is also the third inflection.

  1. Raññā hato poso (the man was killed by the king).
  2. Yakkhena dinno varo (a boon was given by the yakkha).
  3. Ahinā daṭṭho naro (the man was bitten by the snake).
289Kaccāyana Sutta. 297Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Hetvatthe ca (601)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Hetu-atthe + ca = 2 words]

Hetvatthe ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Annena vasati; dhammena vasati; vijjāya vasati; sakkārena vasati.

Also in the meaning of cause.
In the meaning of cause there is also the third inflection.

  1. Annena vasati (lives because of food).
  2. Dhammena vasati (lives because of the Dhamma [because he wants to study the Dhamma]).
  3. Vijjāya vasati (lives because of learning [because he wants to learn]).
  4. Sakkārena vasati (lives because of honor [because he expects honors]).
290Kaccāyana Sutta. 298Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Sattamyatthe ca (602)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Sattamī-atthe + ca = 2 words]

Sattamyatthe ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Tena kālena (Khu. iii, 41)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. iii, p. 41, tena samayena (Vin. i, 1)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. i, p. 1. (Yena kālena, yena samayena)49Footnote: ( ) Sīhaḷapotthake natthi. (What is in parentheses is not in the Sinhalese manuscript.) tena kho pana samayena (Vin. i,7; iii, 1; D. ii, 76)Vinaya-piṭaka · Dīgha-nikāya.

Also in the meaning of the seventh [inflection].
In the meaning of the seventh [inflection] there is also the third inflection.

  1. Tena kālena (at that time).
  2. Tena samayena (on that occasion).
  3. (Yena kālena, yena samayena) tena kho pana samayena (and on that occasion).

49Footnote: ( ) Sīhaḷapotthake natthi. (What is in parentheses is not in the Sinhalese manuscript.)
291Kaccāyana Sutta. 299Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Yen’ aṅgavikāro (603)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Yena + aṅgavikāro = 2 words]

Yena byādhimatā aṅgena aṅgino vikāro lakkhīyate, tattha tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Akkhinā kāṇo; hatthena kuṇī; kāṇaṃ passati nettena; pādena khañjo; piṭṭhiyā khujjo.

Deformation of a limb by that [part].
The deformation of the body is characterized by the limb that is diseased; in that [limb] there is the third inflection.

  1. Akkhinā kāṇo (blind in one eye).
  2. Hatthena kuṇī (crippled in one hand).
  3. Kāṇaṃ passati nettena (sees one who is blind in one eye).
  4. Pādena khañjo (lame in one foot).
  5. Piṭṭhiyā khujjo (humpbacked in the back).
292Kaccāyana Sutta. 300Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Visesane ca (604)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Visesane + ca = 2 words]

Visesanatthe ca tatiyāvibhatti hoti.

Gottena (Khu. iii, 25)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. iii, p. 25 Gotamo nātho; suvaṇṇena abhirūpo; tapasā uttamo.

Also in qualifying.
In the meaning of qualifying there is also the third inflection.

  1. Gottena Gotamo nātho (the Lord Gotama by clan).
  2. Suvaṇṇena abhirūpo (handsome by golden color).
  3. Tapasā uttamo (excellent by ascetic practices).
293Kaccāyana Sutta. 301Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Sampadāne catutthī (605)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Sampadāne + catutthī = 2 words]

Sampadānakārake catutthīvibhatti hoti.

Buddhassa vā Dhammassa vā Saṃghassa vā dānaṃ deti; dātā hoti samaṇassa vā brāhmaṇassa vā (A. i, 524)Aṅguttara-nikāya · vol. i, p. 524.

In the dative, the fourth [inflection].
In the dative case there is the fourth inflection.

  1. Buddhassa vā Dhammassa vā Saṃghassa vā dānaṃ deti ([he] gives a gift to the Buddha, to the Dhamma or to the Saṅgha).
  2. Dātā hoti samaṇassa vā brāhmaṇassa vā (is a giver to the ascetic or to the brahmin).
294Kaccāyana Sutta. 305Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Namoyogādīsv api ca (606)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Namo-yoga-ādīsu + api + ca = 3 words]

Namoyogādīsv api ca catutthīvibhatti hoti.

Namo te Buddhavīr’ atthu (S. i, 48)Saṃyutta-nikāya · vol. i, p. 48; sotthi pajānaṃ; namo karohi nāgassa (M. i, 196)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. i, p. 196; svāgataṃ te mahārāja (Khu. v, 329; vi, 156, 331)Khuddaka-nikāya.

And also in connection with “namo”, homage, etc.
In connection with “namo” (homage), etc., there is also the fourth inflection.

  1. Namo te Buddhavīr’ atthu (oh Buddha, oh Hero, may there be homage to you).
  2. Sotthi pajānaṃ (welfare to the people).
  3. Namo karohi nāgassa (pay homage to the Arahant [nāga]).
  4. Svāgataṃ te mahārāja (welcome to you, great king).
295Kaccāyana Sutta. 307Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Apādāne pañcamī (607)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Apādāne + pañcamī = 2 words]

Apādānakārake pañcamīvibhatti hoti.

Pāpā cittaṃ nivāraye (Khu. i, 30)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 30; abbhā mutto va candimā (Khu. i, 39)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 39, bhayā muccati so naro.

In the ablative, the fifth [inflection].
In the ablative case there is the fifth inflection.

  1. Pāpā cittaṃ nivāraye ([one] should restrain the mind from evil).
  2. Abbhā mutto va candimā (like the moon freed from the cloud).
  3. Bhayā muccati so naro (that man is freed from danger or fear).
296Kaccāyana Sutta. 314Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Kāraṇatthe ca (608)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Kāraṇa-atthe + ca = 2 words]

Kāraṇatthe ca pañcamīvibhatti hoti.

Ananubodhā appaṭivedhā catunnaṃ ariyasaccānaṃ yathābhūtaṃ adassanā (D. ii, 77)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 77.

Also in the meaning of cause.
In the meaning of cause there is also the fifth inflection.

  1. Ananubodhā appaṭivedhā catunnaṃ ariyasaccānaṃ yathābhūtaṃ adassanā (because of not understanding, because of not penetrating, because of not seeing the Four Noble Truths as they really are).
297Kaccāyana Sutta. 284Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Kammatthe dutiyā (580)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Kamma-atthe + dutiyā = 2 words]

Kammatthe dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Gāvaṃ hanati; vīhayo lunāti; satthaṃ karoti; ghaṭaṃ karoti; rathaṃ karoti; dhammaṃ suṇāti (D. i, 93)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. i, p. 93; Buddhaṃ pūjeti; vācaṃ bhāsati (D. ii, 13)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 13; taṇḍulaṃ pacati; coraṃ ghāteti.

In the meaning of the object, the second [inflection].
In the meaning of the object there is the second inflection.

  1. Gāvaṃ hanati ([he] kills the cow).
  2. Vīhayo lunāti (cuts the paddy).
  3. Satthaṃ karoti (makes a book [also: a knife]).
  4. Ghaṭaṃ karoti (makes a water-pot).
  5. Rathaṃ karoti (makes a chariot).
  6. Dhammaṃ suṇāti (hears the Dhamma).
  7. Buddhaṃ pūjeti (honors the Buddha).
  8. Vācaṃ bhāsati (speaks a word).
  9. Taṇḍulaṃ pacati (cooks the rice).
  10. Coraṃ ghāteti (kills the thief).
298Kaccāyana Sutta. 287Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Kāladdhānam accantasaṃyoge (581)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Kāla-addhānaṃ + accanta-saṃyoge = 2 words]

Kāladdhānaṃ accantasaṃyoge dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Māsaṃ maṃsodanaṃ bhuñjati; saradaṃ ramaṇīyā nadī; māsaṃ sajjhāyati. Yojanaṃ vanarāji; yojanaṃ dīgho pabbato; kosaṃ sajjhāyati.

Accantasaṃyoge ti kimatthaṃ? Saṃvacchare bhojanaṃ bhuñjati.

In the constant conjunction of time and space.
When there is constant conjunction of time and of space, there is the second inflection.

  1. Māsaṃ maṃsodanaṃ bhuñjati (eats meat and rice for a month [every day for one month]).
  2. Saradaṃ ramaṇīyā nadī (the river is beautiful during the autumn).
  3. Māsaṃ sajjhāyati (recites for a month).
  4. Yojanaṃ vanarāji (the line of the forest is one yojana long).
  5. Yojanaṃ dīgho pabbato (the mountain is one yojana long).
  6. Kosaṃ sajjhāyati (recites for a kosa [one quarter of a yojana]).

What is the purpose of saying “accantasaṃyoge” (constant conjunction)? [This sutta does not apply when there is no constant conjunction, as in:] Saṃvacchare bhojanaṃ bhuñjati (eats food during the year).

299Kaccāyana Sutta. 288Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Kammappavacanīyayutte (582-586)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Kammappavacanīyayutte = 1 word]

Kammappavacanīyayutte dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Taṃ kho pana bhavantaṃ gotamaṃ evaṃ kalyāṇo kittisaddo abbhuggato (Vin. i, 1; iii, 45; D. i, 46, 83, 104; M. ii, 376)Vinaya-piṭaka · Dīgha-nikāya · Majjhima-nikāya. Pabbajitam anu pabbajiṃsu (D. ii, 25)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 25.

In connection with those that have indicated the action (kammappavacanīya).
In connection with those that have indicated the action there is the second inflection.

  1. Taṃ kho pana bhavantaṃ gotamaṃ evaṃ kalyāṇo kittisaddo abbhuggato (thus the good reputation of that honorable Gotama goes up [spreads]).
  2. Pabbajitam anu pabbajiṃsu (they went forth following the example of the one gone forth [the Bodhisatta]).
300Kaccāyana Sutta. 286Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Gati-buddhi-bhuja-paṭha-hara-kara-sayādīnaṃ kārite vā (587)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Gati-buddhi-bhuja-paṭha-hara-kara-saya-ādīnaṃ + kārite + vā = 3 words]

Gati-buddhi-bhuja-paṭha-hara-kara-sayādīnaṃ payoge kārite dutiyāvibhatti hoti vā.

Puriso purisaṃ (gāmaṃ) gāmayati, puriso purisena vā, puriso purisassa vā. Evaṃ bodhayati, bhojayati, pāṭhayati, hārayati, kārayati, sayāpayati. Evaṃ sabbattha kārite.

Or in the causative of ‘gati’, ‘buddhi’, ‘bhuja’, ‘paṭha’, ‘hara’, ‘kara’, ‘si’, etc.
In connection with the causative of ‘gati’ (going), ‘buddhi’ (knowing), ‘bhuja’ (eating), ‘paṭha’ (reciting), ‘hara’ (carrying), ‘kara’ (doing), ‘saya’ (lying down), etc., there is optionally the second inflection.

  1. Puriso purisaṃ (gāmaṃ) gāmayati (the man causes the man to go to the village); puriso purisena vā, puriso purisassa vā. (The object of the causative can also be in the third inflection, “purisena”, or in the sixth inflection, “purisassa”.)
  2. Thus with “bodhayati”, causes to know; “bhojayati”, causes to eat; “pāṭhayati”, causes to read; “hārayati”, causes to carry; “kārayati”, causes to do; “sayāpayati”, causes to lie down. Thus everywhere in the causative.
301Kaccāyana Sutta. 315Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Sāmismiṃ chaṭṭhī (609)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Sāmismiṃ + chaṭṭhī = 2 words]

Sāmismiṃ chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti.

Tassa bhikkhuno paṭivīso; tassa bhikkhuno patto; tassa bhikkhuno cīvaraṃ; attano mukhaṃ.

In the possessor, the sixth [inflection].
In the possessor there is the sixth inflection.

  1. Tassa bhikkhuno paṭivīso (the portion of that bhikkhu).
  2. Tassa bhikkhuno patto (the bowl of that bhikkhu).
  3. Tassa bhikkhuno cīvaraṃ (the robe of that bhikkhu).
  4. Attano mukhaṃ (the mouth of oneself).
302Kaccāyana Sutta. 319Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Okāse sattamī (630)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Okāse + sattamī = 2 words]

Okāsakārake sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Gambhīre odakantike (Khu. i, 9)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 9; pāpasmiṃ ramati mano (Khu. i, 30)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 30; bhagavati brahmacariyaṃ vussati kulaputto (M. i, 208; ii, 93)Majjhima-nikāya.

In the locative, the seventh [inflection].
In the locative case there is the seventh inflection.

  1. Gambhīre odakantike (in the depth, at the bottom of the water).
  2. Pāpasmiṃ ramati mano (the mind delights in evil).
  3. Bhagavati brahmacariyaṃ vussati kulaputto (the young man of good family practices the holy life in the Blessed One).
303Kaccāyana Sutta. 321Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Sām’-issar’-ādhipati-dāyāda-sakkhī-patibhū-pasuta-kusalehi ca (631)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Sāmi-issara-adhipati-dāyāda-sakkhī-patibhū-pasuta-kusalehi + ca = 2 words]

Sāmī issara adhipati dāyāda sakkhī patibhū pasuta kusala icc etehi payoge chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti, sattamī ca.

Goṇānaṃ sāmī, goṇesu sāmī; goṇānaṃ issaro, goṇesu issaro; goṇānaṃ adhipati, goṇesu adhipati; goṇānaṃ dāyādo, goṇesu dāyādo; goṇānaṃ sakkhī, goṇesu sakkhī; goṇānaṃ patibhū, goṇesu patibhū; goṇānaṃ pasuto, goṇesu pasuto; goṇānaṃ kusalo, goṇesu kusalo.

Also with “sāmī”, “issara”, “adhipati”, “dāyāda”, “sakkhī”, “patibhū”, “pasuta”, “kusala”.
When there is connection with “sāmī” (owner), “issara” (lord), “adhipati” (master), “dāyāda” (heir), “sakkhī” (witness), “patibhū” (guarantor), “pasuta” (engaged in), “kusala” (skillful), there is the sixth inflection and the seventh [inflection].

  1. Goṇānaṃ sāmī, goṇesu sāmī (the owner of the oxen).
  2. Goṇānaṃ issaro, goṇesu issaro (the lord of the oxen).
  3. Goṇānaṃ adhipati, goṇesu adhipati (the master of the oxen).
  4. Goṇānaṃ dāyādo, goṇesu dāyādo (the heir of the oxen).
  5. Goṇānaṃ sakkhī, goṇesu sakkhī (the witness of the oxen).
  6. Goṇānaṃ patibhū, goṇesu patibhū (the guarantor (the one who promises) of the oxen).
  7. Goṇānaṃ pasuto, goṇesu pasuto (engaged in the oxen).
  8. Goṇānaṃ kusalo, goṇesu kusalo (skillful in the oxen).
304Kaccāyana Sutta. 322Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Niddhāraṇe ca (632)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Niddhāraṇe + ca = 2 words]

Niddhāraṇatthe ca chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti, sattamī ca.

Kaṇhā gāvīnaṃ sampannakhīratamā, kaṇhā gāvīsu sampannakhīratamā. Sāmā nārīnaṃ dassanīyatamā, sāmā nārīsu dassanīyatamā. Manussānaṃ khattiyo sūratamo, manussesu khattiyo sūratamo. Pathikānaṃ dhāvanto sīghatamo, pathikesu dhāvanto sīghatamo.

Also in taking out.
In the meaning of taking out (selecting) there is the sixth inflection and the seventh [inflection].

  1. Kaṇhā gāvīnaṃ sampannakhīratamā, kaṇhā gāvīsu sampannakhīratamā (among the cows, the black one has the most milk).
  2. Sāmā nārīnaṃ dassanīyatamā, sāmā nārīsu dassanīyatamā (among the women, the one with golden complexion50Footnote: “Sāmā” can mean both golden complexion and dark complexion. is the most beautiful).
  3. Manussānaṃ khattiyo sūratamo, manussesu khattiyo sūratamo (among humans, the khattiya is the bravest).
  4. Pathikānaṃ dhāvanto sīghatamo, pathikesu dhāvanto sīghatamo (among the travelers, the one who runs is the fastest).

50Footnote: “Sāmā” can mean both golden complexion and dark complexion.
305Kaccāyana Sutta. 323Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Anādare ca (633)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Anādare + ca = 2 words]

Anādare chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti, sattamī ca.

Rudato dārakassa pabbaji, rudantasmiṃ dārake pabbaji.

Also in disregard.
In disregard there is the sixth inflection and the seventh inflection.

  1. Rudato dārakassa pabbaji, rudantasmiṃ dārake pabbaji (despite the crying of the son, [he] went forth).51Footnote: It means that he disregarded the crying of his son and became a monk.

51Footnote: It means that he disregarded the crying of his son and became a monk.
306Kaccāyana Sutta. 289Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Kvaci dutiyā chaṭṭhīnam atthe (588)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Kvaci + dutiyā + chaṭṭhīnaṃ + atthe = 4 words]

Chaṭṭhīnam atthe kvaci dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Api ssu maṃ Aggivessana tisso upamā paṭibhaṃsu (M. i, 307)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. i, p. 307.

Sometimes there is the second [inflection] in the meaning of the sixth [inflection].
Sometimes, in the meaning of the sixth [inflection], there is the second inflection.

  1. Api ssu maṃ Aggivessana tisso upamā paṭibhaṃsu (indeed, Aggivessana, my three similes manifested).
307Kaccāyana Sutta. 290Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Tatiyā-sattamīnañ ca (589)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Tatiyā-sattamīnaṃ + ca = 2 words]

Tatiyā-sattamīnaṃ atthe ca kvaci dutiyāvibhatti hoti.

Sace maṃ samaṇo Gotamo ālapissati (S. i, 179)Saṃyutta-nikāya · vol. i, p. 179; tvañ ca maṃ n’ ābhibhāsasi (Khu. vi, 359)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. vi, p. 359. Evaṃ tatiyatthe.

Pubbaṇhasamayaṃ nivāsetvā (Vin. i, 7; iii, 48; D. ii, 75; M. i, 118)Vinaya-piṭaka · Dīgha-nikāya · Majjhima-nikāya; ekaṃ samayaṃ Bhagavā (D. i, 1)Dīgha-nikāya · vol. i, p. 1. Evaṃ sattamyatthe.

And [in the meaning] of the third and of the seventh [inflection].
Sometimes there is also the second inflection in the meaning of the third and of the seventh [inflection].

  1. Sace maṃ samaṇo Gotamo ālapissati (if the ascetic Gotama speaks to me).
  2. Tvañ ca maṃ n’ ābhibhāsasi (and you will not talk with me).

Thus in the meaning of the third [inflection].

  1. Pubbaṇhasamayaṃ nivāsetvā (having put on the lower robe in the early morning).
  2. Ekaṃ samayaṃ Bhagavā (on one occasion the Blessed One).

Thus in the meaning of the seventh [inflection].

308Kaccāyana Sutta. 317Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Chaṭṭhī ca (634)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Chaṭṭhī + ca = 2 words]

Tatiyā-sattamīnaṃ atthe ca kvaci chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti.

Kato me kalyāṇo, kataṃ me pāpaṃ. Evaṃ tatiyatthe.

Kusalā naccagītassa sikkhitā cāturitthiyo (Khu. vi, 156, 158)Khuddaka-nikāya; kusalo tvaṃ rathassa aṅgapaccaṅgānaṃ (M. ii, 58)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 58. Evaṃ sattamyatthe.

Kvacī ti kimatthaṃ? Yo vo Ānanda mayā dhammo ca vinayo ca desito paññatto. Ānando atthesu vicakkhaṇo.

And the sixth [inflection].
Sometimes there is also the sixth inflection in the meaning of the third and of the seventh [inflection].

  1. Kato me kalyāṇo, kataṃ me pāpaṃ (the good has been done by me; the evil has been done by me).

Thus in the meaning of the third [inflection].

  1. Kusalā naccagītassa sikkhitā cāturitthiyo (graceful women, skilled and trained in dance and song).
  2. Kusalo tvaṃ rathassa aṅgapaccaṅgānaṃ (are you skilled in the different parts of the chariot?).

Thus in the meaning of the seventh [inflection].

What is the purpose of saying “kvaci” (sometimes)? [To show exceptions to this sutta, as in:] Yo vo Ānanda mayā dhammo ca vinayo ca desito paññatto (Ānanda, the Dhamma and the Vinaya that have been preached and established for you by me). Ānando atthesu vicakkhaṇo (Ānanda is skilled in the meanings).

309Kaccāyana Sutta. 318Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Dutiyā-pañcamīnañ ca (640)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Dutiyā-pañcamīnaṃ + ca = 2 words]

Dutiyā-pañcamīnañ ca atthe kvaci chaṭṭhīvibhatti hoti.

Tassa bhavanti vattāro (M. ii, 133-5)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 133-5; sahasā kammassa kattāro. Evaṃ dutiyatthe.

Assavanatā dhammassa parihāyanti (Vin. iii, 6; D. ii, 32, 40; M. i, 224; ii, 292; S. i, 139)Vinaya-piṭaka · Dīgha-nikāya · Majjhima-nikāya · Saṃyutta-nikāya. Kinnu kho ahaṃ tassa sukhassa bhāyāmi (M. i, 313)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. i, p. 313. Sabbe tasanti daṇḍassa (Khu. i, 32)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 32. Sabbe bhāyanti maccuno (Khu. i, 32)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. i, p. 32. Bhīto catunnaṃ āsīvisānaṃ ghoravisānaṃ (S. ii, 381-2)Saṃyutta-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 381-2. Bhāyāmi ghoravisassa nāgassa. Evaṃ pañcamyatthe.

And [in the meaning] of the second and of the fifth [inflection].
Sometimes there is also the sixth inflection in the meaning of the second and of the fifth [inflection].

  1. Tassa bhavanti vattāro (they are the ones who say to him).
  2. Sahasā kammassa kattāro (suddenly they do the action).

Thus in the meaning of the second [inflection].

  1. Assavanatā dhammassa parihāyanti (because of not hearing, they fall away from the Dhamma).
  2. Kinnu kho ahaṃ tassa sukhassa bhāyāmi (why should I be afraid of that happiness?).
  3. Sabbe tasanti daṇḍassa (all tremble at punishment).
  4. Sabbe bhāyanti maccuno (all fear death).
  5. Bhīto catunnaṃ āsīvisānaṃ ghoravisānaṃ (afraid of the four dreadful and poisonous snakes).
  6. Bhāyāmi ghoravisassa nāgassa (I am afraid of a dreadful and poisonous snake).

Thus in the meaning of the fifth [inflection].

310Kaccāyana Sutta. 324Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Kamma-karaṇa-nimittatthesu sattamī (641)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Kamma-karaṇa-nimitta-atthesu + sattamī = 2 words]

Kamma-karaṇa-nimittatthesu sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Sundar’ āvuso ime ājīvakā bhikkhūsu abhivādenti (Vin. i, 313)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. i, p. 313. Evaṃ kammatthe.

Hatthesu piṇḍāya caranti (Vin. iii, 125)Vinaya-piṭaka · vol. iii, p. 125; pattesu piṇḍāya caranti; pathesu gacchanti. Evaṃ karaṇatthe.

Dīpi cammesu haññate (Khu. vi, 172)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. vi, p. 172; kuñjaro dantesu haññate (Khu. vi, 172)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. vi, p. 172. Evaṃ nimittatthe.

The seventh [inflection] in the meanings of object, instrument and cause.
There is the seventh inflection in the meaning of object (kamma), of instrument (karaṇa) and of cause (nimitta).

  1. Sundar’ āvuso ime ājīvakā bhikkhūsu abhivādenti (friend, these good ascetics pay homage to the bhikkhus).

Thus in the meaning of object.

  1. Hatthesu piṇḍāya caranti (they go for alms with the hands).
  2. Pattesu piṇḍāya caranti (they go for alms with the bowls).
  3. Pathesu gacchanti (they go by roads).

Thus in the meaning of instrument.

  1. Dīpi cammesu haññate (the leopard is killed because of its skin).
  2. Kuñjaro dantesu haññate (the elephant is killed because of its tusks).

Thus in the meaning of cause.

311Kaccāyana Sutta. 325Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Sampadāne ca (642)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Sampadāne + ca = 2 words]

Sampadāne ca sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Saṃghe dinnaṃ mahapphalaṃ (Khu. ii, 49)Khuddaka-nikāya · vol. ii, p. 49; saṃghe Gotami dehi (M. iii, 296)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. iii, p. 296; saṃghe te dinne ahañ c’ eva pūjito bhavissāmi (M. iii, 296)Majjhima-nikāya · vol. iii, p. 296.

Also in the sampadāna (dative).
There is also the seventh inflection in the dative.

  1. Saṃghe dinnaṃ mahapphalaṃ (what is given to the Saṅgha brings great fruit).
  2. Saṃghe Gotami dehi (Gotamī, give it to the Saṅgha).
  3. Saṃghe te dinne ahañ c’ eva pūjito bhavissāmi (if it is given by you to the Saṅgha, I too will be honored).
312Kaccāyana Sutta. 326Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Pañcamyatthe ca (643)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Pañcamī-atthe + ca = 2 words]

Pañcamyatthe ca sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Kadalīsu gaje rakkhanti.

Also in the meaning of the fifth [inflection].
There is also the seventh inflection in the meaning of the fifth [inflection].

  1. Kadalīsu gaje rakkhanti (they keep the elephants away from the plantains).
313Kaccāyana Sutta. 327Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Kāla-bhāvesu ca (644)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Kāla-bhāvesu + ca = 2 words]

Kāla-bhāvesu ca kattari payujjamāne sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Pubbaṇhasamaye gato; sāyanhasamaye52Footnote: Sāyanhasamaye (Rū. iii, 327; Sad. iii, 644); sāyaṇhasamaye (Mog. iii, 110). āgato. Bhikkhūsu bhojīyamānesu gato; (bhikkhūsu) bhuttesu āgato. Gosu duyhamānesu gato; (gosu) duddhāsu āgato.

Also in time and state.
When the agent is employed in time (kāla) and in state (bhāva), there is also the seventh inflection.

  1. Pubbaṇhasamaye gato ([he] went in the early morning); sāyanhasamaye āgato ([he] came back in the evening).
  2. Bhikkhūsu bhojīyamānesu gato (when the bhikkhus were being fed, [he] went); (bhikkhūsu) bhuttesu āgato (when the bhikkhus had eaten, [he] came back).
  3. Gosu duyhamānesu gato (when the cows were being milked, [he] went); (gosu) duddhāsu āgato (when the cows had been milked, [he] came back).

52Footnote: Sāyanhasamaye (Rū. iii, 327; Sad. iii, 644); sāyaṇhasamaye (Mog. iii, 110).
314Kaccāyana Sutta. 328Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Upa-’dhyādhik’-issaravacane (645)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Upa-adhi + adhika-issara-vacane = 2 words]

Upa adhi icc etesaṃ payoge adhika-issaravacane sattamīvibhatti hoti.

Upa khāriyaṃ doṇo; upa nikkhe kahāpaṇaṃ. Adhi Brahmadatte Pañcālā, adhi naccesu Gotamī, adhi devesu Buddho.

In the expression of excess (“adhika”) and of authority (“issara”) in connection with ‘upa’ and ‘adhi’.53Translator's note: Nandisena does not translate the title of this sutta; the translation is ours.
There is the seventh inflection in connection with ‘upa’ and ‘adhi’ when they mean “adhika” (excess) and “issara” (authority/superiority).

  1. Upa khāriyaṃ doṇo (a doṇa in excess of a khāri [one khāri plus one doṇa]).54Translator's note: Doṇa and khāri are units of measure for grain in the time of the Buddha.
  2. Upa nikkhe kahāpaṇaṃ (a kahāpaṇa in excess of a nikkha).55Translator's note: Kahāpaṇa and nikkha are coins used in the time of the Buddha.
  3. Adhi Brahmadatte Pañcālā (the Pañcālas are subjects of Brahmadatta).
  4. Adhi naccesu Gotamī (Gotamī is superior to the dancers).
  5. Adhi devesu Buddho (the Buddha is superior to the gods).

53Translator's note: Nandisena does not translate the title of this sutta; the translation is ours.
54Translator's note: Doṇa and khāri are units of measure for grain in the time of the Buddha.
55Translator's note: Kahāpaṇa and nikkha are coins used in the time of the Buddha.
315Kaccāyana Sutta. 329Rūpasiddhi Sutta.Maṇḍit’-ussukkesu tatiyā (646)Saddanīti-Suttamālā Sutta
[Maṇḍita-ussukkesu + tatiyā = 2 words]

Maṇḍita ussukka icc etesv atthesu tatiyāvibhatti hoti, sattamī ca.

Ñāṇena pasīdito, ñāṇasmiṃ vā pasīdito; ñāṇena ussukko, ñāṇasmiṃ vā ussukko Tathāgato vā tathāgatagotto vā.

The third [inflection] with “maṇḍita” (clear) and “ussukka” (zeal).
In the meanings of “maṇḍita” (clear) and of “ussukka” (zeal), there is the third inflection and also the seventh [inflection].

  1. Ñāṇena pasīdito, ñāṇasmiṃ vā pasīdito (clear by understanding or clear in understanding).
  2. Ñāṇena ussukko, ñāṇasmiṃ vā ussukko Tathāgato vā tathāgatagotto vā (the Tathāgata, or one belonging to the clan of the Tathāgata, is energetic by understanding or energetic in understanding).
Iti nāma-kappe kāraka-kappo chaṭṭho kaṇḍo
Thus ends the sixth section, the case chapter in the noun chapter
Kāraka-kappo niṭṭhito
End of the Case Chapter